Psychological Impact of Newborn Screening for 3-Methylcrotonyl-CoA Carboxylase Deficiency: The Parental Experience

3-Methylcrotonyl-CoA carboxylase deficiency (3-MCCD) is a metabolic disorder with a wide clinical spectrum ranging from asymptomatic individuals to severe metabolic decompensation. Following the introduction of expanded newborn screening, a high number of asymptomatic individuals with 3-MCCD were identified, prompting debates about its inclusion in screening panels. In order to inform policy and healthcare decisions regarding the inclusion of 3-MCCD in newborn screening programs, we evaluated the long-term outcomes for newborns with positive results over a decade of screening experience in North-East Italy, as well as the psychological impact on their parents. Of the 336,668 newborns screened between 2014 and 2025, 9 were confirmed to be affected. These infants underwent annual clinical and biochemical assessments, including dried blood spot acylcarnitine profile, plasma free carnitine, and urinary organic acids assays. An emergency protocol was provided to all affected children to manage intercurrent illnesses. An ad hoc survey was developed to assess the psychological impact of the disease on parents. During follow-up (mean age at last visit: 4.2 years), one patient experienced metabolic decompensation during an intercurrent illness, which was promptly treated. One patient presented with growth retardation and another with transient psychomotor delay. Five patients developed carnitine deficiency, requiring supplementation. Psychological assessments revealed an initial high level of parental psychological impact, which decreased over time. All parents strongly supported the screening program. Newborn screening for 3-MCCD enabled the early identification and management of affected individuals, thereby avoiding severe metabolic decompensation. Although there is an initial psychological burden on parents, it significantly decreases over time. Therefore, the long-term benefits of newborn screening for 3-MCCD seem to outweigh the psychological drawbacks.