Traditional Machine Learning Outperforms EEGNet for Consumer-Grade EEG Emotion Recognition: A Comprehensive Evaluation with Cross-Dataset Validation

These findings challenge the assumption that architectural complexity universally improves biosignal processing performance in consumer-grade applications. Through the comparison of traditional ML against the EEGNet consumer-grade architecture, we highlight the potential that domain-specific feature engineering and lightweight adaptation techniques can provide superior accuracy, stability, and practical deployment capabilities for consumer-grade EEG emotion recognition. While our empirical comparison focused on EEGNet, the underlying principles regarding data efficiency, noise robustness, and the value of domain expertise could extend to comparisons with other complex architectures facing similar constraints in further research. This comprehensive domain adaptation framework enables robust cross-system deployment, addressing critical gaps in real-world BCI applications.