Temporally consistent tri ledger settlement enables robust and noncontestable coordination in interprovincial power systems

Inter-provincial electricity transactions within China’s unified power market are complicated by spatial heterogeneity, asynchronous dispatch timelines, and strategic deviations in bilateral commitments. Existing mechanisms often struggle with ex-post contestability, temporal inconsistencies, and poor alignment between real-time system conditions and deviation pricing, undermining the market’s fairness and reliability. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel Tri-Ledger Coordinated Settlement (TCS) framework with built-in temporal consistency. The tri-ledger design consists of (1) a Contract Ledger capturing day-ahead bilateral schedules, (2) a Dispatch Ledger reflecting system-level nodal redispatch outcomes, and (3) a Deviation Ledger reconciling discrepancies across provinces through an enforceable and tamper-resistant protocol. Central to this framework is a Distributionally Robust Deviation Pricing (DRDP) model, which penalizes deviation behaviors not based on deterministic thresholds but through ambiguity-aware dual pricing anchored in Wasserstein-ball uncertainty sets. This allows the pricing system to anticipate manipulative strategies while offering probabilistic fairness to genuine imbalances caused by renewables or congestion. Furthermore, a Non-Contestable Decoupled Execution Mechanism (NCDEM) is developed to isolate provincial profit zones during redispatch operations, ensuring that a province cannot benefit by manipulating its declared bilateral trades or influencing others’ deviation compensations. The proposed approach guarantees strategy-proofness under minimal information assumptions and supports distributed execution by provincial grid companies without centralized re-optimization. The effectiveness of the framework is demonstrated on a stylized multi-province testbed derived from China’s Eastern and Central grid clusters. Numerical experiments show that the DRDP-based settlement leads to over 18.4% improvement in fairness-adjusted social welfare and reduces strategic deviation incentives by up to 73% compared to deterministic baseline models. Sensitivity analyses validate robustness under multiple load and RES penetration scenarios. The proposed TCS framework offers policy-relevant insights for implementing transparent and resilient provincial electricity market settlements under China’s “dual-track” trading architecture.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Scientific Reports
Published
2025-12-04
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-28933-3
Primary Topic
Electric Power System Optimization
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Temporally consistent tri ledger settlement enables robust and noncontestable coordination in interprovincial power systems

Wenbao Hu, Cunqiang Huang, Zhongfu Tan, Xue Ma et al.
Scientific Reports
Electric Power System Optimization
article

Temporally consistent tri ledger settlement enables robust and noncontestable coordination in interprovincial power systems

Wenbao Hu, Cunqiang Huang, Zhongfu Tan, Xue Ma, ShuoShuo Lv
article en

Abstract

Inter-provincial electricity transactions within China’s unified power market are complicated by spatial heterogeneity, asynchronous dispatch timelines, and strategic deviations in bilateral commitments. Existing mechanisms often struggle with ex-post contestability, temporal inconsistencies, and poor alignment between real-time system conditions and deviation pricing, undermining the market’s fairness and reliability. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel Tri-Ledger Coordinated Settlement (TCS) framework with built-in temporal consistency. The tri-ledger design consists of (1) a Contract Ledger capturing day-ahead bilateral schedules, (2) a Dispatch Ledger reflecting system-level nodal redispatch outcomes, and (3) a Deviation Ledger reconciling discrepancies across provinces through an enforceable and tamper-resistant protocol. Central to this framework is a Distributionally Robust Deviation Pricing (DRDP) model, which penalizes deviation behaviors not based on deterministic thresholds but through ambiguity-aware dual pricing anchored in Wasserstein-ball uncertainty sets. This allows the pricing system to anticipate manipulative strategies while offering probabilistic fairness to genuine imbalances caused by renewables or congestion. Furthermore, a Non-Contestable Decoupled Execution Mechanism (NCDEM) is developed to isolate provincial profit zones during redispatch operations, ensuring that a province cannot benefit by manipulating its declared bilateral trades or influencing others’ deviation compensations. The proposed approach guarantees strategy-proofness under minimal information assumptions and supports distributed execution by provincial grid companies without centralized re-optimization. The effectiveness of the framework is demonstrated on a stylized multi-province testbed derived from China’s Eastern and Central grid clusters. Numerical experiments show that the DRDP-based settlement leads to over 18.4% improvement in fairness-adjusted social welfare and reduces strategic deviation incentives by up to 73% compared to deterministic baseline models. Sensitivity analyses validate robustness under multiple load and RES penetration scenarios. The proposed TCS framework offers policy-relevant insights for implementing transparent and resilient provincial electricity market settlements under China’s “dual-track” trading architecture.

Scientific ReportsVol. 16(1)
North China Electric Power University (CN), Qinghai New Energy (China) (CN)
Openalex Percentile: Top 61%
Electric Power System Optimization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.