Community–Academic Collaboration for Sargassum Clean-Up and Coastal Monitoring in Xcalak, Southern Mexican Caribbean

Unprecedented quantities of pelagic sargassum since 2011 have demanded technical and management responses. Inappropriate measures might worsen environmental impacts, particularly in low-income regions and protected natural areas that also require low-cost, socio-ecologically integrated alternatives. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness and local perception of sargassum clean-up treatments developed through a community–academic collaboration within a socio-ecological systems framework in the marine protected area Xcalak Reefs National Park (PNAX), at the southernmost Mexican Caribbean coast. In 2019 and 2021, clean-up efforts were implemented through the national PROREST program and a self-organized community group of 35–40 members supported by a multidisciplinary research advisory team. Monitoring in 2021 estimated sargassum removal at 4012 m2 over 50–75 work hours. Although average shoreline retreat was obtained (δmean = −0.22 m), final accretion of ~0.96 m alleviated community concerns about erosion linked to clean-up activities. The most effective and socially accepted clean-up treatment involved sargassum spreading, collection, drying, and revetment-type beach protection, reducing odors and harmful fauna. However, treatments aimed at shoreline stabilization were impractical, raising doubts about their long-term efficacy. These findings highlight the relevance of integrating ecological performance and social perception in sargassum management, especially where co-management with local communities in marine protected areas is needed.