Analysis of trajectories and developmental prospects of research on carlin-type gold deposits on the basis of big data community detection algorithms

• Pioneering Methodology: Applies graph-based community detection (CiteSpace) to map the 56-year knowledge trajectory and developmental prospects of Carlin-type gold deposit research, overcoming limitations of traditional reviews. • Theoretical Advancement: Proposes the universally applicable “multi-source fluids – tectonic activation – nano-scale occurrence” system and the spiral cognitive model (phenomenon → mechanism → system → prediction), extending relevance beyond Carlin-type deposits. • Actionable Pathways: Provides technology-driven solutions (multiscale characterization, AI-enhanced prospecting, eco-extraction) and global collaboration frameworks to address challenges in reserve expansion, sustainable extraction, and theory refinement. The rise of big data analytics and knowledge graph technology has introduced a new paradigm for research on mineral deposits. This study employs CiteSpace, a graph-based community detection tool, to analyze the Web of Science Core Collection literature (1969–2025) on Carlin-type gold deposits, with the aim of identifying global research trajectories, collaboration networks, key themes, frontiers, and future directions. The evolution of research encompasses five distinct phases: the Foundational Period (1969–1990), Domain-expanding Period (1991–2000), Refinement Period (2001–2010), Integration Period (2011–2020), and the ongoing Transformative Leap Period (2021–2025). Geographically, studies have expanded from their origin in Nevada, U.S., to a global scale. Methodologically, advancements have progressed from macro-geological mapping to atomic-scale characterization, accompanied by a theoretical shift towards an integrated “multi-source fluids – tectonic activation – nano-scale occurrence” system. This progression follows a spiral cognitive model: phenomenon description → mechanism analysis → system modeling → predictive application. The international collaboration network has evolved into a “dual-core leadership with multi-tier synergy” framework, where core nations (China and the U.S.) drive cutting-edge theoretical exploration by leveraging their giant ore clusters, while secondary nodes (e.g., Canada, Iran, Australia) enhance research scope and depth through critical regional analogues and cross-deposit-type expertise. Emerging participants (e.g., Malaysia) inject new dynamism and alternative genetic perspectives. Research leadership has transitioned from early dominance by U.S. institutions (e.g., USGS) to prominence of Chinese entities (e.g., Chinese Academy of Sciences, China University of Geosciences) post-2010. Core research themes include: (1) ore formation-regional tectonic coupling, (2) ore-forming fluid dynamics, (3) microscopic gold occurrence and mineralization processes, (4) resource utilization challenges, and (5) integration of multi-technique methodologies and intelligent exploration. Current research frontiers focus on: metallogenic chronology and geodynamic settings, multi-source fluid evolution and tectonic-lithologic coupling, invisible gold occurrence mechanisms, exploration technology innovation and deep targeting, and integrated studies across diverse deposit types. Future priorities center on two pillars: (1) Technological innovation: integrating techniques such as APT, NanoSIMS, and in situ isotopic methods for “atom-mineral-deposit-region” multiscale modeling; applying machine learning to overcome deep-prediction bottlenecks for intelligent “geology-geochemistry-geophysics-remote sensing” prospecting; and developing eco-leaching/microbial oxidation processes for the efficient extraction of gold and associated critical elements (As, Sb, Hg, Fe, S) from refractory ores. (2) International collaboration: establishing unified deposit testing standards; creating a global data-sharing platform; and deepening strategic partnerships through core-core, core-secondary, and core-emerging nation collaborations. These coordinated advancements are poised to drive breakthroughs in reserve expansion, extraction efficiency, sustainable resource development, and the refinement of metallogenic theory

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Ore Geology Reviews
Published
2025-11-24
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2025.106989
Primary Topic
Geochemistry and Geologic Mapping
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Analysis of trajectories and developmental prospects of research on carlin-type gold deposits on the basis of big data community detection algorithms

Qinping Tan, Lulin Zheng, Aamir Khan, Xiaotong Yu et al.
Ore Geology Reviews
Geochemistry and Geologic Mapping
article

Analysis of trajectories and developmental prospects of research on carlin-type gold deposits on the basis of big data community detection algorithms

Qinping Tan, Lulin Zheng, Aamir Khan, Xiaotong Yu, Yongzhang Zhou, Jianzhong Liu, Ruizhong Hu, Biaobiao Zhu, Zhuojun Xie
article en

Abstract

• Pioneering Methodology: Applies graph-based community detection (CiteSpace) to map the 56-year knowledge trajectory and developmental prospects of Carlin-type gold deposit research, overcoming limitations of traditional reviews. • Theoretical Advancement: Proposes the universally applicable “multi-source fluids – tectonic activation – nano-scale occurrence” system and the spiral cognitive model (phenomenon → mechanism → system → prediction), extending relevance beyond Carlin-type deposits. • Actionable Pathways: Provides technology-driven solutions (multiscale characterization, AI-enhanced prospecting, eco-extraction) and global collaboration frameworks to address challenges in reserve expansion, sustainable extraction, and theory refinement. The rise of big data analytics and knowledge graph technology has introduced a new paradigm for research on mineral deposits. This study employs CiteSpace, a graph-based community detection tool, to analyze the Web of Science Core Collection literature (1969–2025) on Carlin-type gold deposits, with the aim of identifying global research trajectories, collaboration networks, key themes, frontiers, and future directions. The evolution of research encompasses five distinct phases: the Foundational Period (1969–1990), Domain-expanding Period (1991–2000), Refinement Period (2001–2010), Integration Period (2011–2020), and the ongoing Transformative Leap Period (2021–2025). Geographically, studies have expanded from their origin in Nevada, U.S., to a global scale. Methodologically, advancements have progressed from macro-geological mapping to atomic-scale characterization, accompanied by a theoretical shift towards an integrated “multi-source fluids – tectonic activation – nano-scale occurrence” system. This progression follows a spiral cognitive model: phenomenon description → mechanism analysis → system modeling → predictive application. The international collaboration network has evolved into a “dual-core leadership with multi-tier synergy” framework, where core nations (China and the U.S.) drive cutting-edge theoretical exploration by leveraging their giant ore clusters, while secondary nodes (e.g., Canada, Iran, Australia) enhance research scope and depth through critical regional analogues and cross-deposit-type expertise. Emerging participants (e.g., Malaysia) inject new dynamism and alternative genetic perspectives. Research leadership has transitioned from early dominance by U.S. institutions (e.g., USGS) to prominence of Chinese entities (e.g., Chinese Academy of Sciences, China University of Geosciences) post-2010. Core research themes include: (1) ore formation-regional tectonic coupling, (2) ore-forming fluid dynamics, (3) microscopic gold occurrence and mineralization processes, (4) resource utilization challenges, and (5) integration of multi-technique methodologies and intelligent exploration. Current research frontiers focus on: metallogenic chronology and geodynamic settings, multi-source fluid evolution and tectonic-lithologic coupling, invisible gold occurrence mechanisms, exploration technology innovation and deep targeting, and integrated studies across diverse deposit types. Future priorities center on two pillars: (1) Technological innovation: integrating techniques such as APT, NanoSIMS, and in situ isotopic methods for “atom-mineral-deposit-region” multiscale modeling; applying machine learning to overcome deep-prediction bottlenecks for intelligent “geology-geochemistry-geophysics-remote sensing” prospecting; and developing eco-leaching/microbial oxidation processes for the efficient extraction of gold and associated critical elements (As, Sb, Hg, Fe, S) from refractory ores. (2) International collaboration: establishing unified deposit testing standards; creating a global data-sharing platform; and deepening strategic partnerships through core-core, core-secondary, and core-emerging nation collaborations. These coordinated advancements are poised to drive breakthroughs in reserve expansion, extraction efficiency, sustainable resource development, and the refinement of metallogenic theory

Ore Geology ReviewsVol. 188
Sun Yat-sen University (CN), Guizhou University (CN), Chinese Academy of Sciences (CN), Institute of Geochemistry (CN), Bureau of Geology and Mineral Exploration and Development of Guizhou Province (CN), University of Chinese Academy of Sciences (CN)
Openalex Percentile: Top 81%
Geochemistry and Geologic Mapping
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.