Ethnographic documentation of the primitive beliefs of the Slavs in the archives of the 18th-20th centuries: Methodology, representation, problems of interpretation

The relevance of the study was determined by the need to analyse how, throughout the eighteenth-twentieth centuries, approaches to recording, classifying, and interpreting the pre-Christian beliefs of the Slavs changed under the influence of political, confessional, and scientific transformations. The aim of the work was to trace the full sequence of transformations – from field recording to archival classification and public representation – and to determine which methodological and ideological factors determined the final structure of the sources. The methodology was based on a comparative analysis of handwritten corpora, censorship prescriptions, and mass publications using the concepts of the history of knowledge, critical archival studies, textual criticism, and sociolinguistic hermeneutics. It was established that in the eighteenth-nineteenth centuries, field records were created mainly by descriptive intuitive methods, and the criterion of authenticity was defined by the aesthetic and ethnopolitical expectations of collectors, which led to the systematic exclusion of syncretic and everyday forms of ritual practice. The analysis of archival classifications showed that administrative-territorial and genre rubrics separated ritual data from functional context, while standardised questionnaires, editorial reductions, and self-censorship transformed multilayered descriptions into unified statistical units. The comparison of handwritten sources with lubok publications and early cinematographic plots demonstrated that at the turn of the nineteenth-twentieth centuries, religious motifs of demonology and agrarian magic were represented mainly as decorative ethnographic markers consistent with the Enlightenment canons of the era. The generalisation of the results confirmed that multilevel selection, classification, and editorial processing stabilised certain interpretative models, while simultaneously marginalising contextual variations and situational practices of the bearers of tradition. The practical value of the study lay in the creation of a set of criteria for reconstructing the original ritual context from fragmentary and conceptually altered sources, contributing to a deeper understanding of ethnographic materials within archival and scholarly practices

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Society Document Communication
Published
2025-01-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.69587/sdc/2.2025.32
Primary Topic
Central European national history
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Ethnographic documentation of the primitive beliefs of the Slavs in the archives of the 18th-20th centuries: Methodology, representation, problems of interpretation

Oleksandr Lakhno
Society Document Communication
Central European national history
article

Ethnographic documentation of the primitive beliefs of the Slavs in the archives of the 18th-20th centuries: Methodology, representation, problems of interpretation

Oleksandr Lakhno
article en

Abstract

The relevance of the study was determined by the need to analyse how, throughout the eighteenth-twentieth centuries, approaches to recording, classifying, and interpreting the pre-Christian beliefs of the Slavs changed under the influence of political, confessional, and scientific transformations. The aim of the work was to trace the full sequence of transformations – from field recording to archival classification and public representation – and to determine which methodological and ideological factors determined the final structure of the sources. The methodology was based on a comparative analysis of handwritten corpora, censorship prescriptions, and mass publications using the concepts of the history of knowledge, critical archival studies, textual criticism, and sociolinguistic hermeneutics. It was established that in the eighteenth-nineteenth centuries, field records were created mainly by descriptive intuitive methods, and the criterion of authenticity was defined by the aesthetic and ethnopolitical expectations of collectors, which led to the systematic exclusion of syncretic and everyday forms of ritual practice. The analysis of archival classifications showed that administrative-territorial and genre rubrics separated ritual data from functional context, while standardised questionnaires, editorial reductions, and self-censorship transformed multilayered descriptions into unified statistical units. The comparison of handwritten sources with lubok publications and early cinematographic plots demonstrated that at the turn of the nineteenth-twentieth centuries, religious motifs of demonology and agrarian magic were represented mainly as decorative ethnographic markers consistent with the Enlightenment canons of the era. The generalisation of the results confirmed that multilevel selection, classification, and editorial processing stabilised certain interpretative models, while simultaneously marginalising contextual variations and situational practices of the bearers of tradition. The practical value of the study lay in the creation of a set of criteria for reconstructing the original ritual context from fragmentary and conceptually altered sources, contributing to a deeper understanding of ethnographic materials within archival and scholarly practices

Society Document Communication
Openalex Percentile: Top 55%
Central European national history
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Ethnographic documentation of the primitive beliefs of the Slavs in the archives of the 18th-20th centuries: Methodology, representation, problems of interpretation — Oleksandr Lakhno · Society Document Communication (2025) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS