Tycho Supernova Exploded Inside a Planetary Nebula (SNIP)

I analyze recent X-ray data from the literature of the type Ia supernova remnant (SNR Ia) Tycho and conclude that Tycho is a SN Ia inside a planetary nebula (SNIP), strengthening such a previous suggestion from 1985. The observations reveal two opposite protrusions, termed ears, projected on the main shell of Tycho. The pair of ear structures qualitatively resembles that of the SNRs Ia Kepler, SNR G299-2.9, and SNR G1.9+0.3, which earlier studies considered as SNIPs. The requirement that the explosion occurs within hundreds of thousands of years after the formation of the planetary nebula (by the second star to evolve) makes the core-degenerate scenario the most likely for Tycho, with the double-degenerate with merger to explosion delay time scenario somewhat less likely. Several other possible scenarios lead to a SNIP, but they are unlikely for Tycho. The identification of Tycho as a SNIP leads to two general conclusions. (1) The fraction of SNIPs among normal SNe Ia is very large, ≈70–90%. Thus, the vast majority of normal SNe Ia are SNIPs. (2) To accommodate the large fraction of SNIPs, the delay time distribution of normal SNe Ia includes not only the stellar evolution timescale (as usually assumed), but also includes pockets of younger stellar populations in galaxies without ongoing star formation; the SNIPs come from the younger stellar populations in galaxies.