North American Caballines and Amerhippines of the Past 1 Million Years (Part 1)

Horses were widely distributed in North America during the Pleistocene epoch and their fossil remains are common in sedimentary deposits of this age. Despite their rich fossil record, the systematics and taxonomy of North American Pleistocene horses remain unresolved. We evaluated a large sample of cranial and postcranial horse fossils of Irvingtonian and Rancholabrean North American Land Mammal Age. In this study, we present Part 1 of our evaluation, which centers on caballine horses, Equus (Equus). We present data (measurements and photographs) and analyses (Simpson’s ratio diagrams, scatter diagrams, and anatomical comparisons) that reveal morphological variation in North American caballine horses. These analyses serve as the basis for recognizing different morphospecies: E. (E.) scotti, E. (E.) alaskae, E. (E.) lambei (the latter two possibly representing “ecological variants” of a single species), E. (E.) niobrarensis, E. (E.) pacificus, and E. (E.) complicatus. How these morphospecies (or chronospecies or ecological variants) were phylogenetically related remains to be evaluated. Equus (E.) hatcheri may be considered as a morphological variant or chronological variant of E. (E.) niobrarensis. Equus holmesi is considered a junior synonym of E. (E.) scotti, while E. bautistensis may be regarded as a junior synonym of E. (E.) pacificus. Equus laurentius is a junior synonym of E. (E.) caballus, a synonymy proposed previously in other studies. We are uncertain about the nature of E. midlandensis. In addition, we identify morphometric and anatomical features that distinguish between Equus (Equus), North American Equus (Amerhippus), and Equus (Hesperohippus) mexicanus. This study aims to advance our understanding of the taxonomy of North American Pleistocene horses, providing a thoroughly documented catalogue as a basis for further studies.