A comparison of short- and long-read whole-genome sequencing for microbial pathogen epidemiology

Genome assembly and variant calling are important steps in microbial population studies and epidemiology. Most variant calling and genotyping pipelines are designed for Illumina short sequencing reads. Oxford Nanopore Technology long-read sequencing results in more complete genome assemblies but has historically been of lower quality. Here, we show that Nanopore long reads are now of sufficient quality for bacterial whole-genome assembly and epidemiology. We benchmarked the accuracy of multiple variant calling pipelines with short and long reads. Using an optimized variant calling approach, variant calls and genotypes inferred from long reads are as accurate as those inferred from short reads. Importantly, we found that gold-standard variant calling pipelines designed for short reads are also accurate with long reads when long reads are first fragmented into shorter sequences. This finding allows researchers to incorporate the advantages of Nanopore sequencing for genome assembly while maintaining high accuracy in epidemiology and population analyses.