Stability of oxygen diffusivity and aeration indicators in soilless growth media under wetting–drying cycles

In soilless cultivation systems, the growing medium plays a crucial role in supplying water, oxygen, and physical support for roots. Its properties may change with time and repeated wetting and drying (W/D) cycles. This study aimed to evaluate the stability of aeration indicators and oxygen diffusion parameters in fourteen growing media, focusing on changes in the relative oxygen diffusion coefficient ( D p / D 0 ) after 10 W/D cycles. Mixtures of mineral substrates, biochars, and agricultural residues were assessed for bulk density, mass loss, organic matter change, physical stability, and D p / D 0 . The D p was measured on samples equilibrated at matric suctions of 5, 10, 20, 40, 60, and 80 hPa using the one-chamber method. The D p / D 0 vs. air-filled porosity (AFP) data were modeled using Millington–Quirk and Troeh equations. Results showed that W/D cycles reduced structural stability, increased pore tortuosity, and decreased D p / D 0 in most media. However, mixtures with perlite, rockwool, and stable biochars preserved favorable aeration. The Troeh model showed better fit to the D p / D 0 –AFP data and is recommended. The AFP alone proved insufficient to assess aeration; pore tortuosity and continuity must also be considered. Among the substrates tested, rockwool (0.1)-perlite [RW(0.1)-Perlite], rockwool (0.2)-perlite [RW(0.2)-Perlite], wheat straw–vermiculite (WS-V), and sawdust–sugarcane bagasse biochar produced at 300 °C –vermiculite–zeolite (Sd-SCB300-V-Z) are recommended as stable growing media with high D p / D 0 and reuse potential. These findings emphasize the importance of carefully selecting raw materials and intelligently designing the growing medium to simultaneously achieve physical stability, oxygen supply efficiency, and economic feasibility in sustainable greenhouse production. • Wetting/drying cycles significantly/differently altered oxygen diffusivity of growth media. • Wetting/drying cycles increased micropores and pore tortuosity in growth media. • Increase in micropores and tortuosity due to wetting/drying cycles reduced oxygen diffusivity. • Oxygen diffusivity is a better and reliable aeration indicator than air-filled porosity. • Rockwool-perlite, wheat straw–vermiculite, and sawdust–sugarcane bagasse biochar–vermiculite–zeolite were stable with high oxygen diffusivity.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Agricultural Water Management
Published
2025-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2025.109953
Primary Topic
Soil and Unsaturated Flow
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Stability of oxygen diffusivity and aeration indicators in soilless growth media under wetting–drying cycles

Mohammad Reza Mosaddeghi, H. Shariatmadari, Shahrokh Shahmansouri
Agricultural Water Management
Soil and Unsaturated Flow
article

Stability of oxygen diffusivity and aeration indicators in soilless growth media under wetting–drying cycles

Mohammad Reza Mosaddeghi, H. Shariatmadari, Shahrokh Shahmansouri
article en

Abstract

In soilless cultivation systems, the growing medium plays a crucial role in supplying water, oxygen, and physical support for roots. Its properties may change with time and repeated wetting and drying (W/D) cycles. This study aimed to evaluate the stability of aeration indicators and oxygen diffusion parameters in fourteen growing media, focusing on changes in the relative oxygen diffusion coefficient ( D p / D 0 ) after 10 W/D cycles. Mixtures of mineral substrates, biochars, and agricultural residues were assessed for bulk density, mass loss, organic matter change, physical stability, and D p / D 0 . The D p was measured on samples equilibrated at matric suctions of 5, 10, 20, 40, 60, and 80 hPa using the one-chamber method. The D p / D 0 vs. air-filled porosity (AFP) data were modeled using Millington–Quirk and Troeh equations. Results showed that W/D cycles reduced structural stability, increased pore tortuosity, and decreased D p / D 0 in most media. However, mixtures with perlite, rockwool, and stable biochars preserved favorable aeration. The Troeh model showed better fit to the D p / D 0 –AFP data and is recommended. The AFP alone proved insufficient to assess aeration; pore tortuosity and continuity must also be considered. Among the substrates tested, rockwool (0.1)-perlite [RW(0.1)-Perlite], rockwool (0.2)-perlite [RW(0.2)-Perlite], wheat straw–vermiculite (WS-V), and sawdust–sugarcane bagasse biochar produced at 300 °C –vermiculite–zeolite (Sd-SCB300-V-Z) are recommended as stable growing media with high D p / D 0 and reuse potential. These findings emphasize the importance of carefully selecting raw materials and intelligently designing the growing medium to simultaneously achieve physical stability, oxygen supply efficiency, and economic feasibility in sustainable greenhouse production. • Wetting/drying cycles significantly/differently altered oxygen diffusivity of growth media. • Wetting/drying cycles increased micropores and pore tortuosity in growth media. • Increase in micropores and tortuosity due to wetting/drying cycles reduced oxygen diffusivity. • Oxygen diffusivity is a better and reliable aeration indicator than air-filled porosity. • Rockwool-perlite, wheat straw–vermiculite, and sawdust–sugarcane bagasse biochar–vermiculite–zeolite were stable with high oxygen diffusivity.

Agricultural Water ManagementVol. 322
Isfahan University of Technology (IR)
Openalex Percentile: Top 65%
Soil and Unsaturated Flow
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.