Characteristics of the Novel Electron Beam Hardening Technology for Submicron Bainitic Steels in the Context of Its Application in the Production of Gears and Comparison with the Competitive Laser Beam Technology

The objective of this study was to investigate electron beam hardening (EBH) technology and compare its performance with laser beam hardening (LBH) in the context of manufacturing components such as gears, which increasingly employ submicron bainitic steels. Given the stringent demands for durability and fatigue resistance of gear teeth, identifying an optimal surface hardening method is essential for extending service life. Comprehensive analyses, including light and electron microscopy, hardness testing, tribocorrosion testing, and X-ray diffraction for phase composition, were conducted. The EBH-treated layer exhibited a slightly higher hardness (by 26 HV) compared to the LBH-treated layer (average 654 HV), while the base material measured 393 HV. The EBH process produced a uniform hardness distribution with a subsurface zone of reduced hardness. In contrast, LBH resulted in a surface oxide layer absent in EBH due to its vacuum environment. Both techniques reduced the residual austenite content in the surface layer from 22.5% to approximately 1.3%–1.4%. Notably, EBH achieved comparable hardening effects with nearly half the energy input of LBH, demonstrating superior energy efficiency and industrial feasibility. Application of the developed EBH process to an actual gear component confirmed its practical potential for modern gear manufacturing.