Techno-Economic Analysis of Membrane-Based Plants for H2/CH4 Purification

In the context of the growing adoption of alternative gas separation processes, combined with the interest in hydrogen as a fuel and energy carrier, the use of membrane technology in H₂/CH₄ purification is analyzed in this work, focusing on the techno-economic aspects. In particular, the separation and economic performance of three Pd-Ag/Si-CHA membrane plants are simulated, aiming to achieve high degrees of purity and recovery paired with cost-effective configurations. A single Pd-Ag membrane stage operating at 20 atm and 350 °C can theoretically guarantee a CH₄ concentration of 95%, while a completely pure H₂ stream leaves the plant as a permeate product. The choice of a less selective Si-CHA membrane allows a temperature reduction but implies the use of more stages to achieve the desired CH₄ target. In addition, H₂ purity does not exceed 98%. A two-stage hybrid process, in which the retentate gas leaving the Pd-Ag membrane is cooled and fed to the Si-CHA unit, is also a cost-effective solution, as feed pressure can be reduced to 10 atm with significant compression cost savings. All the configurations are able to provide positive values of economic potential (EP); however, the single Pd-Ag membrane plant is the best option since it guarantees the highest EP, net profit and net present value (NPV).