A Metagenomic and Colorimetric Analysis of the Biological Recolonization Occurring at the “Largo da Porta Férrea” Statues (Coimbra UNESCO World Heritage Site), After Cleaning Interventions

Biological recolonization after cleaning remains a major challenge for the conservation of stone cultural heritage. As recolonization can start within months to a few years following intervention, developing rapid, field-deployable diagnostic approaches is crucial to better monitor microbial reappearance and to assess treatment performance in real time. Traditional evaluation methods lack the capacity to take into consideration non-cultivable microorganisms or assess functional traits relevant to recolonization. To bypass this gap, we applied on-site direct Whole-Genome Sequencing (Oxford Nanopore® MinION™ sequencer) coupled with colorimetric analysis to understand the microbiome, resistome, and metabolic traits of subaerial biofilms present in untreated and treated (recolonized) areas of stone statues at the “Largo da Porta Férrea” (Coimbra’s UNESCO World Heritage site). Colorimetric analysis (ΔE of 32–40 in recolonized vs. 19–43 in untreated areas) and genomic data pointed out that the applied treatment provided only a short-term effect (roughly 4–5 years), with a marked decline in fungi (1–2% vs. 7–18%), coupled with an increased recolonization mainly by Cyanobacteriota (circa 35–45%) and several stress-resistant Bacteria (globally ~95% of reads vs. 73–79% in controls). Antimicrobial resistance profiles significantly differed between sites, with treated areas showing distinct and unique resistance genes, and plasmids containing the blaTEM-116 gene, which can indicate potential adaptive shifts in the resistomes profiles after intervention. Metabolic pathways analysis revealed that untreated areas retained more complete nitrogen and sulfur cycling gene sets, whereas treated areas showed reduced biogeochemical gene contents, consistent with earlier-stage recolonization steps. Given the current recolonization detection and the ongoing biofilm formation, routine monitoring efforts (e.g., every 6 months) are recommended. Overall, this study demonstrates the first on-site genomic characterization of recolonization events on heritage stone, providing a practical prompt-warning tool for conservation monitoring and future biofilm management strategies.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Applied Sciences
Published
2025-11-06
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/app152111843
Primary Topic
Building materials and conservation
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

A Metagenomic and Colorimetric Analysis of the Biological Recolonization Occurring at the “Largo da Porta Férrea” Statues (Coimbra UNESCO World Heritage Site), After Cleaning Interventions

João Trovão, Conceição Egas, Lídia Catarino, Fabiana Soares
Applied Sciences
Building materials and conservation
article

A Metagenomic and Colorimetric Analysis of the Biological Recolonization Occurring at the “Largo da Porta Férrea” Statues (Coimbra UNESCO World Heritage Site), After Cleaning Interventions

João Trovão, Conceição Egas, Lídia Catarino, Fabiana Soares
article en

Abstract

Biological recolonization after cleaning remains a major challenge for the conservation of stone cultural heritage. As recolonization can start within months to a few years following intervention, developing rapid, field-deployable diagnostic approaches is crucial to better monitor microbial reappearance and to assess treatment performance in real time. Traditional evaluation methods lack the capacity to take into consideration non-cultivable microorganisms or assess functional traits relevant to recolonization. To bypass this gap, we applied on-site direct Whole-Genome Sequencing (Oxford Nanopore® MinION™ sequencer) coupled with colorimetric analysis to understand the microbiome, resistome, and metabolic traits of subaerial biofilms present in untreated and treated (recolonized) areas of stone statues at the “Largo da Porta Férrea” (Coimbra’s UNESCO World Heritage site). Colorimetric analysis (ΔE of 32–40 in recolonized vs. 19–43 in untreated areas) and genomic data pointed out that the applied treatment provided only a short-term effect (roughly 4–5 years), with a marked decline in fungi (1–2% vs. 7–18%), coupled with an increased recolonization mainly by Cyanobacteriota (circa 35–45%) and several stress-resistant Bacteria (globally ~95% of reads vs. 73–79% in controls). Antimicrobial resistance profiles significantly differed between sites, with treated areas showing distinct and unique resistance genes, and plasmids containing the blaTEM-116 gene, which can indicate potential adaptive shifts in the resistomes profiles after intervention. Metabolic pathways analysis revealed that untreated areas retained more complete nitrogen and sulfur cycling gene sets, whereas treated areas showed reduced biogeochemical gene contents, consistent with earlier-stage recolonization steps. Given the current recolonization detection and the ongoing biofilm formation, routine monitoring efforts (e.g., every 6 months) are recommended. Overall, this study demonstrates the first on-site genomic characterization of recolonization events on heritage stone, providing a practical prompt-warning tool for conservation monitoring and future biofilm management strategies.

Applied SciencesVol. 15(21)
Biocant (PT), University of Coimbra (PT)
Openalex Percentile: Top 65%
Building materials and conservation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.