Determinants of Needleleaf and Broadleaf Decomposition Rates Under and Outside the Parent Tree Stand

We studied differences in the decomposition rate between Pinus merkusii Jungh. et de Vriese (tusam) leaves, a representative of needle leaf litter, and Diospyros celebica Bakh. (ebony) leaves, a representative of broadleaf litter, in three forest communities (Karst, Lowland, Pine) on the island of Sulawesi, Indonesia, and identified their determinants. Twenty-four 1 m × 1 m quadrats were set up in each forest community to observe the in situ decomposition process. Near each quadrat, 1 m2 litter traps were set to monitor litter production. In addition, 30 litter bags containing tusam leaves and 30 litter bags containing ebony leaves were spread in the three forest communities, in both the dry and wet seasons, to observe their decomposition rate during each season. The ANOVA test showed that the one-year in situ Decomposition Rate Constant (k) was significantly highest in the Karst forest (0.0921/year), followed by the Lowland forest (0.0700/year), and the lowest in the Pine forest (0.0277/year). During the dry season, the mean k-value of tusam leaves was significantly faster than ebony leaves in Karst (0.7162/6 months for tusam, 0.3840/6 months for ebony) and Lowland forests (0.3472/6 months for tusam, 0.1017/6 months for ebony), but on the contrary, it is slower in the Pine forest (0.0498/6 months for tusam, 0.0745/6 months for ebony). During the wet season, there was no significant difference between the mean k-value of tusam leaves compared to ebony leaves in the Karst (0.5217/4 months for tusam, 0.4859/4 months for ebony) and Lowland (0.2397/4 months for tusam, 0.2098/4 months for ebony) forests, but in the Pine forest, the mean k-value of ebony leaves was significantly higher than that of tusam leaves (0.0942/4 months for tusam, 0.1650/4 months for ebony). This study explains that the decomposition process of leaf litter is complex, species-specific, and is controlled by a combination of factors. Extrinsic factors play a more critical role than intrinsic factors in determining the k-value. The low rate of decomposition of tusam leaves under its mother tree stands is not caused by intrinsic factors, but rather by extrinsic factors that inhibit the growth of decomposing agents.