Successional Patterns of Plant and Animal Diversity Under Contrasting Restoration Modes in Typical Coal-Mine Wastelands of Southwestern China

Ecological restoration of mine wastelands is central to biodiversity conservation and ecosystem recovery worldwide. However, the long-term ecological consequences of active restoration versus natural regeneration remain debated, particularly in mountainous karst landscapes. Using a space-for-time substitution, we established a five-stage chronosequence—recently abandoned, 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, and a late-successional forest (>35 years)—in a typical underground coal-mine wasteland in eastern Yunnan, southwest China. Each age class contained paired active restoration and natural regeneration sites; the late-successional forest served as a reference. We surveyed nested vegetation plots (20 × 20 m with shrub and herb subplots) in summer and autumn, recorded vertebrate species with camera traps, and quantified α-diversity (species richness, Shannon–Wiener diversity, Simpson’s diversity, Pielou’s evenness) and β-diversity (Bray–Curtis dissimilarity, non-metric multidimensional scaling). Overall plant α-diversity was highest in natural regeneration and lowest in active restoration, whereas tree-layer diversity was highest in active restoration and shrub and herb layers were richer under natural regeneration. Preliminary data from our camera traps suggested that animal species richness ranked late-successional forest > natural regeneration > active restoration, but evenness peaked in active restoration, suggesting early-stage homogenization. Plant β-diversity indicated stronger compositional divergence among active restoration sites and greater similarity between natural regeneration and the reference forest; both modes converged toward the reference forest over time but followed distinct patterns. These findings suggest that active restoration accelerates structural development yet increases between-site heterogeneity, whereas natural regeneration maintains higher overall diversity and compositional similarity to reference communities. Our results provide preliminary empirical guidance for selecting restoration strategies in similar karst coal-mine landscapes.