Comparative Accuracy Assessment of Unmanned and Terrestrial Laser Scanning Systems for Tree Attribute Estimation in an Urban Mediterranean Forest

Urban mediterranean forests are key components of urban ecosystems. Accurate, high-resolution data on forest structural attributes are essential for effective management. This study evaluates the efficiency of unmanned laser scanning systems (ULS) and terrestrial LiDAR (TLS) in deriving key tree attributes, diameter at breast height (DBH) and tree height, within a small urban park in Zadar, Croatia. Accuracy assessment of the ULS and TLS-derived DBH was conducted based on traditional ground-based measurement (TGBM) data. For ULS, an automatic Spatix workflow was applied that classified points into a Tree class, segmented trees using trunk-based logic, and estimated DBH by fitting a circle to a 1.3 m slice; tree height was computed from the ground-normalized cloud with the Output Tree Cells tool. A semi-automatic CloudCompare/ArcMap workflow used CSF ground filtering, Connected Components segmentation, extraction of a 10 cm slice, manual trunk vectorization, and DBH calculation via Minimum Bounding Geometry. TLS scans, processed in FARO SCENE, were then analyzed in Spatix using the same automatic trunk-fitting procedure to derive DBH and height. Accuracy for DBH was evaluated against TGBM; comparative performance was summarized with standard error metrics, while ULS and TLS tree heights were compared using Concordance Correlation Coefficient (CCC) and Bland–Altman statistics. Results indicate that the semi-automatic approach outperformed the automatic approach in deriving DBH. TLS-derived DBH values demonstrated higher consistency and agreement with TGBM, as evidenced by their strong linear correlation, minimal bias, and narrow residual spread, while ULS exhibited greater variability and systematic deviation. Tree height comparisons between ULS and TLS revealed that ULS consistently produced slightly higher and more uniform measurements. This study highlights limitations in the evaluated techniques and proposes a hybrid approach combining ULS scanning with personal laser scanning (PLS) systems to enhance data accuracy in urban forest assessments.