Stoichiometry of HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein protomers with changes that stabilize or destabilize the pretriggered conformation

During human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) entry into host cells, binding to the receptors, CD4 and CCR5/CXCR4, triggers conformational changes in the metastable envelope glycoprotein (Env) trimer ((gp120-gp41)₃). CD4 binding induces Env to make transitions from its pretriggered conformation (PTC) to more "open" conformations that are sensitive to inhibition by antibodies, CD4-mimetic compounds (CD4mcs), and exposure to cold. Changes in functional membrane Envs that either stabilize or destabilize the PTC have been identified. Here, we investigate the stoichiometric requirements for the PTC-stabilizing and -destabilizing changes in the Env protomers. To this end, we generated viruses bearing Envs with mixed protomers exhibiting different degrees of PTC stability and determined the sensitivity of the viruses to cold (0°C) and, in some cases, to a CD4mc. The number of stabilized Env protomers required to achieve stabilization of the PTC was inversely related to the degree of PTC stabilization that resulted from the introduced Env change. For strongly stabilizing Env changes, modification of a single protomer was sufficient to achieve PTC stabilization; apparently, with adequate stability, the modified protomer can constrain the conformation of the other two protomers to maintain the PTC. Weakly stabilizing Env changes needed to be present in all three protomers to achieve efficient stabilization of the PTC. In many cases, the PTC was disrupted when destabilizing changes were present in only a single protomer. These complementary results suggest that conformational symmetry among the protomers of the functional Env trimer is conducive to the integrity of the PTC.IMPORTANCEThe human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein (Env) trimer consists of three protomers. In response to receptor binding, the flexible Env changes its conformation to mediate virus entry into host cells. The shape-shifting ability of Env also contributes to HIV-1's capacity to evade the host immune system. The pretriggered (state 1) conformation (PTC) of Env is an important target for virus entry inhibitors and host antibodies but is unstable and therefore incompletely characterized. Changes in Env amino acids that either stabilize or destabilize the PTC have been identified. Here, we define how many Env protomers need to be modified by these changes to achieve stabilization or destabilization of the PTC. These results can guide the placement of changes in the HIV-1 Env protomers to control the movement of the Env trimer from the PTC, allowing better characterization of this elusive conformation and testing of its utility in vaccines.