Expert Perspectives on Enhancing Analytical Methods for Multi-Ingredient Dietary Supplements (MIDS): A Qualitative Study

The increasing demand for multi-ingredient dietary supplements (MIDS), driven by diverse consumer health needs, has introduced analytical challenges in product testing and quality control. These challenges stem from complex ingredient interactions, formulation variability, and the diverse physicochemical properties of the individual components. To examine these issues and explore practical solutions, this study employed semi-structured focus group interviews with 33 industry professionals and 10 analytical experts from academic and industry. Professionals reported major obstacles including the degradation or loss of trace components, interferences among ingredients, analytical difficulties with specific dosage forms, and the lack of standardized testing protocols. To mitigate these challenges, professionals reported implementing various combination strategies including substituting problematic raw materials and modifying analytical instruments and pretreatment procedures, in order to improve test reproducibility. These measures were developed internally and varied significantly across companies, reflecting the absence of a unified analytical framework for MIDS testing. Building on these insights, the analytical experts proposed systematic improvements including developing matrix-specific pretreatment protocols and optimized extraction strategies as well as regulatory harmonization to enhance analytical reliability and reproducibility. These findings provide critical insights into current field practices and inform the development of standardized methodologies for the analysis and quality assurance of MIDS.