Discovery of Cryptic Mussel Biodiversity in the Genera Pleurobema and Pleuronaia Using Molecular Phylogenetics and Morphology, with Descriptions of a New Species and a Previously Synonymized Species

Freshwater mussels in the genera Fusconaia, Pleurobema, and Pleuronaia are similar in their external shell morphology, which has made the identification and classification of species within these genera difficult and led to many taxonomic revisions. Large samples (N = 464) of select mussel species in these genera were collected from 2012 through 2014, primarily in the upper Tennessee River basin of Tennessee and Virginia, USA. Mitochondrial ND1 and nuclear ITS1 DNA sequences were analyzed to assess phylogenetic relationships among taxa. Ten species were verified as phylogenetically distinct at ND1, two of which were cryptic and previously unrecognized species. Described herein as Pleurobema parmaleei and Pleuronaia estabrookianus, each species clade was diverged at this gene region by ~3.0% from the respective closest congener. The nuclear ITS1 gene region’s nucleotide-site insertion/deletion (indel) patterns were analyzed as single mutational events rather than as fifth character states or missing data. Most species, including these two, were phylogenetically distinct at the ITS1 region when incorporating indels into analyses, but some estimated interspecific pairwise distances were lower than corresponding intraspecific estimates. Among morphological traits assessed for each species, differences in foot color and gravidity characteristics illustrated differences between phylogenetically recognized species and their closest congeners. Due to the limited known geographical distributions of these two cryptic species, each may require protection under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. While this study collected large sample sizes for each species, many streams in the basin remain unsampled and could potentially contain populations of these species or additional cryptic species.