Provenance and selective quarrying of New Kingdom Nubian sandstones on Sai Island, Sudan: Insights from ilmenite alterations and matrix compositions

• All Nubian sandstones from Sai Island show highly similar petrography. • Ilmenite alteration series and similar matrix compositions are present in all samples. • Fe-Ti-oxide assemblages indicate a common late-stage magmatic provenance. • Temple sandstones are finer-grained, lighter, and more homogeneous than quarry samples. • Sandstones were likely intentionally selected for Temple A. This study examines the mineralogical composition and alteration products of ilmenite and the matrix in Nubian sandstones from Temple A and ancient quarries on Sai Island (northern Sudan) for insights into their provenance. We characterized the grains and their diagenetic alteration products via polarized light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and Raman spectroscopy. All samples, deriving from Late Bronze Age contexts (c. 15th–14th cent. BCE), are dominated by quartz (>90 %), minor feldspar (<10 %), and rare lithoclasts (<5%). Depending on the amount of matrix (5–50 %), the sandstones are classified as quartz arenites or quartz wackes. Generally, temple sandstones are moderately sorted, smaller-grained (250 μm to 310 μm), and lighter colored, compared to quarry samples, which are (very) poorly sorted, larger-grained (190 μm to 750 μm), and darker. All sandstone samples bear ilmenite alteration products (pseudorutile, rutile, anatase, hematite, Fe-hydroxides) and have matrices composed of kaolinite and illite, indicating similar weathering, diagenetic, and burial histories. The grains derive from a pluton and the Fe-Ti-oxide assemblage before alteration was consistently ilmenite with minor rutile and hematite, which suggests a late-stage magmatic source with comparable temperature and oxygen fugacity conditions for all samples. The results indicate that all investigated samples likely originate from the same or closely related stratigraphic units. The mineralogical homogeneity precludes precise attribution of temple blocks to specific quarries, however, the difference between moderately sorted temple and (very) poorly sorted quarry sandstones could be explained by selective quarrying by ancient builders to ensure aesthetic and material consistency in construction.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Archaeological Science Reports
Published
2025-10-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2025.105370
Citations
2
Primary Topic
Ancient Egypt and Archaeology
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
16.55
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Provenance and selective quarrying of New Kingdom Nubian sandstones on Sai Island, Sudan: Insights from ilmenite alterations and matrix compositions

Rosemarie Klemm, Melanie Kaliwoda, Julia Budka, Fabian Dellefant
2 citations
Journal of Archaeological Science Reports
Ancient Egypt and Archaeology
16.55
article

Provenance and selective quarrying of New Kingdom Nubian sandstones on Sai Island, Sudan: Insights from ilmenite alterations and matrix compositions

Rosemarie Klemm, Melanie Kaliwoda, Julia Budka, Fabian Dellefant
article en
2 citations

Abstract

• All Nubian sandstones from Sai Island show highly similar petrography. • Ilmenite alteration series and similar matrix compositions are present in all samples. • Fe-Ti-oxide assemblages indicate a common late-stage magmatic provenance. • Temple sandstones are finer-grained, lighter, and more homogeneous than quarry samples. • Sandstones were likely intentionally selected for Temple A. This study examines the mineralogical composition and alteration products of ilmenite and the matrix in Nubian sandstones from Temple A and ancient quarries on Sai Island (northern Sudan) for insights into their provenance. We characterized the grains and their diagenetic alteration products via polarized light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and Raman spectroscopy. All samples, deriving from Late Bronze Age contexts (c. 15th–14th cent. BCE), are dominated by quartz (>90 %), minor feldspar (<10 %), and rare lithoclasts (<5%). Depending on the amount of matrix (5–50 %), the sandstones are classified as quartz arenites or quartz wackes. Generally, temple sandstones are moderately sorted, smaller-grained (250 μm to 310 μm), and lighter colored, compared to quarry samples, which are (very) poorly sorted, larger-grained (190 μm to 750 μm), and darker. All sandstone samples bear ilmenite alteration products (pseudorutile, rutile, anatase, hematite, Fe-hydroxides) and have matrices composed of kaolinite and illite, indicating similar weathering, diagenetic, and burial histories. The grains derive from a pluton and the Fe-Ti-oxide assemblage before alteration was consistently ilmenite with minor rutile and hematite, which suggests a late-stage magmatic source with comparable temperature and oxygen fugacity conditions for all samples. The results indicate that all investigated samples likely originate from the same or closely related stratigraphic units. The mineralogical homogeneity precludes precise attribution of temple blocks to specific quarries, however, the difference between moderately sorted temple and (very) poorly sorted quarry sandstones could be explained by selective quarrying by ancient builders to ensure aesthetic and material consistency in construction.

Journal of Archaeological Science ReportsVol. 67
Bavarian Natural History Collections (DE), Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München (DE)
Openalex Percentile: Top 1%
Ancient Egypt and Archaeology
16.55
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.