Field Vibration Monitoring for Detecting Stiffness Variations in RC, PSC, Steel, and UHPC Bridge Girders

This study quantifies shear and flexural stiffnesses and their changes over time to support structural health monitoring of in-service bridge superstructures across four girder types: reinforced concrete (RC) beams, prestressed concrete (PSC) girders, steel girders, and ultra-high-performance concrete (UHPC) sections, using field ambient vibration testing. A total of 20 bridges across Georgia and Iowa are assessed, involving over 100 hours of on-site data collection and traffic control strategies. Results show that field-measured natural frequencies differ from theoretical predictions by average of 30–35% for RC, and 20–25% for PSC, 15–25% for steel and 2% for UHPC, reflecting the complexity of in situ structural dynamics and challenges in estimating material properties. Site-placed RC beams showed stiffness reduction due to deterioration, whereas prefabricated PSC girders maintained consistent stiffness with predictable variations. UHPC sections exhibited the highest stiffness, reflecting superior performance. Steel girders matched theoretical values, but a span-level test revealed that deck damage can reduce frequencies undetected by localized measurements. Importantly, vibration-based measurements revealed reductions in structural stiffness that were not apparent through conventional visual inspection, particularly in RC beams. The research significance of this work lies in establishing a portfolio-based framework that enables cross-comparison of stiffness behavior across multiple girder types, providing a scalable and field-validated approach for system-level bridge health monitoring and serving as a quantitative metric to support bridge inspections and decision-making.