Feasibility of a Low-Cost MEMS Accelerometer for Tree Dynamic Stability Analysis: A Comparative Study with Seismic Sensors

Urban trees are subjected to stressful conditions caused by anthropogenic, biotic, and abiotic factors. These stressors can cause structural changes, increasing the risks of branch failure or even complete uprooting. To mitigate the risks to people’s safety, administrators must assess and evaluate the health and structural stability of trees. Risk analysis typically takes into account environmental vulnerability and tree characteristics, assessed at a specific point in time. However, although dynamic tests play a crucial role in risk assessment in urban environments, the high cost of the sensors significantly limits their widespread application across large tree populations. For this reason, the present study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of low-cost sensors in monitoring tree dynamics. A low-cost micro-electro-mechanical systems (MEMS) sensor is tested in the laboratory and the field using a pull-and-release test, and its performance is compared with that of seismic reference accelerometers. The collected data are analyzed and compared in terms of both the frequency and time domains. To obtain reliable measurements, the accelerations must be generated by substantial dynamic excitations, such as high wind events or abrupt changes in loading conditions. The results show that the MEMS sensor has lower accuracy and higher noise compared to the seismic sensor; however, the MEMS can still identify the main peaks in the frequency domain compared to the seismic sensor, provided that the input amplitude is sufficiently high.