Comparing Surface and Deep Learning Strategies and Their Relationship to High School Students' Academic Performance in Science

The strategies students use in their learning processes are crucial to their academic success, particularly in complex subjects like science. Students' preferred learning strategies can significantly influence their academic performance as they navigate scientific concepts. This study examined the relationship between academic achievement and the utilization of deep and surface learning strategies among high school students at a private institution in Carmen, Cebu, Philippines. It seeks to understand how these strategies influence science learning and suggests teaching practices to promote a practical learning experience. A mixed-method approach was employed, integrating quantitative data from a standardized questionnaire with qualitative insights from student interviews. A sample of 101 students was selected from 136 participants, determined using RAOSOFT, ensuring a 95% confidence level and a 5% margin of error. The study utilized the Revised Two-Factor Study Process Questionnaire (R-SPQ-2F) to assess learning strategies. Findings showed that high-performing students preferred deep learning strategies, though the correlation with performance was weak. Moderate academic performers used both strategies, while low performers relied on surface learning, which was linked to lower achievement. Promoting deep learning strategies alongside surface learning, especially for lower-performing students, is recommended to foster curiosity and motivation to improve academic performance and achieve long-term success.