Stream Restoration for the Spawning of Trout: How to Enhance the Egg to Fry Survival and to Monitor the Spawning Efficiency?

ABSTRACT Today, salmonid management is largely based on river restoration. One of the fundamental elements is the creation of functional spawning sites. Key values of sedimentological characteristics must be defined in terms of granulometry, permeability, and oxygen concentration to ensure the best possible success of the operations. These values for the egg‐to‐fry survival were estimated in three countries (Slovenia, Sweden, and Switzerland) on three salmonid species (brown, marble, and sea trout) across 22 streams and 109 sites. The permeability of the substrate was contingent upon the concentration of fine sediment. The presence of fine particles (with a diameter of less than 1–15 mm) in the substrate at a proportion of 38%–47% resulted in a permeability reduction by a factor of 10. In order for permeability to be significant, the geometrical diameter ( d g ) of the substrate must exceed 15 mm (Fredle Index, F i < 7). To obtain the same oxygen concentration inside the gravel as at the surface itself, permeability must exceed 5000 cm/h. In order to observe at least 80% of the oxygen concentration observed at the surface in the interstitial water, the diameter of the substrate must be at least 17.0 mm ( F i > 5.0). The interstitial oxygen concentration may decline to below 80% of the value observed at the surface when the substrate contains 30% or more of fines sediments smaller than 4 mm, 26% of fines smaller than 2 mm, and 22% of fines smaller than 1 mm. The impact of sediment on the interstitial oxygen concentration was found to be greater the finer the sediment was. A reduction in the interstitial oxygen concentration to below 7.5 mg/L (68% of saturation) resulted in a survival rate of less than 30% for eggs at the eyed stage. When the granulometry ( d g ) of the substrate was greater than 20 mm ( F i > 7.0), the survival of the eggs to the eyed stage was at least 60%. Therefore, it can be concluded that when restoration programs are planned, it is essential to consider these values in order to increase the success of natural spawning of the trout.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
River Research and Applications
Published
2025-10-11
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/rra.70061
Primary Topic
Fish Ecology and Management Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Stream Restoration for the Spawning of Trout: How to Enhance the Egg to Fry Survival and to Monitor the Spawning Efficiency?

Aurélie Rubin, Alain J. Crivellì, Rubin Jean‐François, Damien Robert‐Charrue
River Research and Applications
Fish Ecology and Management Studies
article

Stream Restoration for the Spawning of Trout: How to Enhance the Egg to Fry Survival and to Monitor the Spawning Efficiency?

Aurélie Rubin, Alain J. Crivellì, Rubin Jean‐François, Damien Robert‐Charrue
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT Today, salmonid management is largely based on river restoration. One of the fundamental elements is the creation of functional spawning sites. Key values of sedimentological characteristics must be defined in terms of granulometry, permeability, and oxygen concentration to ensure the best possible success of the operations. These values for the egg‐to‐fry survival were estimated in three countries (Slovenia, Sweden, and Switzerland) on three salmonid species (brown, marble, and sea trout) across 22 streams and 109 sites. The permeability of the substrate was contingent upon the concentration of fine sediment. The presence of fine particles (with a diameter of less than 1–15 mm) in the substrate at a proportion of 38%–47% resulted in a permeability reduction by a factor of 10. In order for permeability to be significant, the geometrical diameter ( d g ) of the substrate must exceed 15 mm (Fredle Index, F i < 7). To obtain the same oxygen concentration inside the gravel as at the surface itself, permeability must exceed 5000 cm/h. In order to observe at least 80% of the oxygen concentration observed at the surface in the interstitial water, the diameter of the substrate must be at least 17.0 mm ( F i > 5.0). The interstitial oxygen concentration may decline to below 80% of the value observed at the surface when the substrate contains 30% or more of fines sediments smaller than 4 mm, 26% of fines smaller than 2 mm, and 22% of fines smaller than 1 mm. The impact of sediment on the interstitial oxygen concentration was found to be greater the finer the sediment was. A reduction in the interstitial oxygen concentration to below 7.5 mg/L (68% of saturation) resulted in a survival rate of less than 30% for eggs at the eyed stage. When the granulometry ( d g ) of the substrate was greater than 20 mm ( F i > 7.0), the survival of the eggs to the eyed stage was at least 60%. Therefore, it can be concluded that when restoration programs are planned, it is essential to consider these values in order to increase the success of natural spawning of the trout.

River Research and ApplicationsVol. 42(1)
HES-SO University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland (CH), Rivier University (US), HES-SO Genève (CH), Tour du Valat (FR), University of Lausanne (CH)
Openalex Percentile: Top 72%
Fish Ecology and Management Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.