Validation of Multi-Scale LAI Products in Heterogeneous Terrain-Based UAV Images

Significant uncertainties persist across different Leaf Area Index (LAI) products due to multiple factors; therefore, the accuracy assessment of the global LAI products is an indispensable step before their application. In this study, comprehensive validation of multi-scale LAI products including Sentinel-2, Landsat-8/9, and MCD15A3H was implemented utilizing fine-resolution LAI maps which were based on UAV images and field-measured LAI data. The validation results demonstrated a consistent, systematic underestimation across all the LAI products within the study area, the RMSE of these products ranged from 0.56 to 1.63, and the coarse-resolution MCD15A3H LAI product demonstrated highest accuracy (RMSE = 0.56, R2 = 0.69). The Sentinel-2 products exhibited intermediate accuracy among all those products (RMSE: 1.16–1.36). The Landsat-8/9 LAI product showed markedly lower accuracy relative to Sentinel-2; its RMSE (1.63) exceeded that of Sentinel-2 10 m LAI and 20 m LAI by 40.52% and 21.64%, respectively. In addition, all these LAI products showed consistent seasonal variation patterns with the reference LAI maps. Moreover, Sentinel-2 10 m LAI products showed serious underestimation for all vegetation types, with forests providing the highest RMSE = 0.89. This study serves as a valuable reference for the application of multi-scale LAI products in heterogeneous terrain and provides directions for the improvement of fine-resolution LAI retrieval algorithms.