Facilitators and barriers to recruitment and engagement with a randomised controlled trial in mental health services: experiences of trial participants and intervention providers

Many randomised controlled trials struggle to recruit and follow-up participants and struggle to achieve high rates of trial intervention take-up and sustained engagement. Few previous studies explore participants’ experiences of recruitment and engagement in trials in secondary mental health care contexts, and few include the perspectives of control group participants. We sought to address this knowledge gap in a sub-study of the Community Navigator trial, a multi-site UK trial of a novel, co-produced, social intervention for people with treatment-resistant depression (TRD) in secondary care community mental health teams. We used a mixed methods approach to explore barriers and facilitators to trial recruitment and retention, intervention engagement, and how these factors may persist and inter-relate. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 17 trial participants from the intervention group and with intervention providers: eight Community Navigators and one supervisor, across four UK sites. An online survey was sent to the first 100 trial participants, including those allocated to the intervention and control groups, which could be completed anonymously. Collaborative framework analysis was used by the research team and lived experience advisory panel (LEAP) to analyse interview, focus group and survey data. Factors helping and hindering trial recruitment and engagement were described in three overarching themes: The Trial Context, Skilled Communication, and The Complexity of Depression and Anxiety. Facilitators included maximising choice for participants at all stages, a kind and patient approach and striking the correct balance between too much and too little information about the trial. A novel finding was that researchers initiate a “virtuous cycle”, where participants’ initial good experience generates optimism about future involvement in the trial and the experimental treatment. Barriers to recruitment and engagement included referring clinicians providing inaccurate initial information to service users, overwhelming volumes of information, concern about randomisation to the control group, and service users’ internal barriers regarding their mental health. Future trials in mental health contexts should use training to encourage a patient and flexible approach from researchers; provide key trial information more than once; ensure involved clinical teams are also communicating about the trial accurately to potential participants; and consider how to minimise disappointment following allocation to a control group. A good early experience of the research process can help trial retention and generate therapeutic optimism about the trial intervention. Registered on 8 July 2022: ISRCTN 13205972.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Trials
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-026-10086-x
Primary Topic
Ethics in Clinical Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Facilitators and barriers to recruitment and engagement with a randomised controlled trial in mental health services: experiences of trial participants and intervention providers

Prisha Shah, Vanessa Pinfold, Sonia Johnson, Jo Billings et al.
2 links
Trials
Ethics in Clinical Research
article

Facilitators and barriers to recruitment and engagement with a randomised controlled trial in mental health services: experiences of trial participants and intervention providers

Prisha Shah, Vanessa Pinfold, Sonia Johnson, Jo Billings, Brynmor Lloyd‐Evans, Beverley Chipp, Georgia Naughton, Maev Conneely, Hannah Gray, Glyn Lewis, Gareth Ambler, Steven Marwaha, Tanya Mackay, Chandani Nekitsing, Martin Webber, Gamze Evlat, Zubair Matin, Jerusaa Vasikaran, Hameed Khan, Manisha Jain, Nick Barber, Ailsa McGuinness, Jessica Lashko
article en

Abstract

Many randomised controlled trials struggle to recruit and follow-up participants and struggle to achieve high rates of trial intervention take-up and sustained engagement. Few previous studies explore participants’ experiences of recruitment and engagement in trials in secondary mental health care contexts, and few include the perspectives of control group participants. We sought to address this knowledge gap in a sub-study of the Community Navigator trial, a multi-site UK trial of a novel, co-produced, social intervention for people with treatment-resistant depression (TRD) in secondary care community mental health teams. We used a mixed methods approach to explore barriers and facilitators to trial recruitment and retention, intervention engagement, and how these factors may persist and inter-relate. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 17 trial participants from the intervention group and with intervention providers: eight Community Navigators and one supervisor, across four UK sites. An online survey was sent to the first 100 trial participants, including those allocated to the intervention and control groups, which could be completed anonymously. Collaborative framework analysis was used by the research team and lived experience advisory panel (LEAP) to analyse interview, focus group and survey data. Factors helping and hindering trial recruitment and engagement were described in three overarching themes: The Trial Context, Skilled Communication, and The Complexity of Depression and Anxiety. Facilitators included maximising choice for participants at all stages, a kind and patient approach and striking the correct balance between too much and too little information about the trial. A novel finding was that researchers initiate a “virtuous cycle”, where participants’ initial good experience generates optimism about future involvement in the trial and the experimental treatment. Barriers to recruitment and engagement included referring clinicians providing inaccurate initial information to service users, overwhelming volumes of information, concern about randomisation to the control group, and service users’ internal barriers regarding their mental health. Future trials in mental health contexts should use training to encourage a patient and flexible approach from researchers; provide key trial information more than once; ensure involved clinical teams are also communicating about the trial accurately to potential participants; and consider how to minimise disappointment following allocation to a control group. A good early experience of the research process can help trial retention and generate therapeutic optimism about the trial intervention. Registered on 8 July 2022: ISRCTN 13205972.

Trials
McPin Foundation (GB), North London NHS Foundation Trust (GB), University College London (GB), University of York (GB), University of Birmingham (GB)
National Institute for Health and Care Research, Department of Health and Social Care
Good health and well-being
Ethics in Clinical Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon