Reducing quantum resources for attacking S-AES on quantum devices

The Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) is one of the most widely used symmetric block cipher cryptography algorithms. Simplified-AES (S-AES) retains the structural framework of AES, making it an ideal model for elucidating the mechanism of symmetric cryptography. In this paper, we investigate potential quantum attacks on S-AES, utilizing both Grover-based algorithms and variational quantum algorithms (VQAs). For Grover-based attacks, we introduce an optimized oracle for implementing S-AES, reducing the complexity from 160 Toffoli gates to 120 by refining the SubNibble operation. Additionally, we propose a general Variational Quantum Attack Algorithm (VQAA) for any type of symmetric encryption that does not require the quantum implementation of the encryption procedure, which reduces the gate complexity substantially. These improvements enable the implementation of both Grover-based attacks and VQAA on superconducting quantum computers. The results demonstrate the feasibility of cryptographic analysis on currently available quantum hardware. Our findings also underscore the challenges of parameter optimization for S-AES, attributing the difficulty to the design of efficient parameterized quantum circuits, which constrain the effectiveness of variational algorithms. Despite these advancements, significant challenges remain in achieving quantum attacks on AES.