Species’ urbanization time but not present urban tolerance predicts avian fear responses towards human

We found that the timing of urban colonization better predicts reduced fear of humans in birds than present-day urban tolerance, emphasizing the role of long-term behavioral filtering and/or selection in shaping urban wildlife behavior. By explicitly separating urbanization time from contemporary urban commonness within a single city and analyzing individual-level fear responses, our study shows that earlier urban colonizers exhibit consistently shorter escape distances, reflecting cumulative long-term processes rather than short-term plasticity alone. These findings highlight the importance of incorporating urban colonization history into behavioral ecology and urban wildlife management frameworks.