Expanding the Fine-Kinney Methodology Using Fuzzy Logic: A Case Study in an Energy Linemen Workshop

This paper investigates the effectiveness and limitations of the traditional Fine-Kinney method for occupational risk assessment, emphasizing its shortcomings in addressing complex and dynamic work environments. To overcome these challenges, two advanced methodologies, Fine-Kinney10 (FK10) and Fuzzy Fine-Kinney10 (FFK10), are introduced. The FK10 employs a symmetric scaling system (1–10) for probability, frequency, and severity indicators, providing a more balanced quantification of risks. Meanwhile, FFK10 incorporates fuzzy logic to handle uncertainty and subjectivity in risk assessment, significantly enhancing the sensitivity and accuracy of risk evaluation. These methodologies were applied to a linemen workshop in an energy production and distribution company, analyzing various types of accidents such as falls from heights, exposure to electric currents, slips on surfaces, and more. The applications highlighted the practical benefits of these methods in effectively assessing and mitigating risks. A significant finding includes the identification of risks related to falls from heights of <2.5 m (SH1) and road traffic accidents (SH6), where all three methods yielded different verbal outcomes. Compared to the traditional Fine-Kinney method, FK10 and FFK10 demonstrated superior ability in distinguishing risk levels and guiding targeted safety measures. The study underscores that FK10 and FFK10 represent significant advancements in occupational risk management, offering robust frameworks adaptable across various industries.