Vernacular Architecture and Indoor Environmental Satisfaction: A Systematic Review of Influencing Factors

This systematic literature review investigates the factors influencing indoor environmental satisfaction in vernacular architecture, with particular attention to sustainability and sociocultural contexts. Drawing on 105 peer-reviewed studies published over the past two decades, the analysis employed thematic synthesis and cluster analysis to identify key design features, theoretical underpinnings, and variables affecting occupant satisfaction. Five major theories emerged, with Sustainability Theory, Bioclimatic Architecture Theory, and Ecological Systems Theory most frequently applied. Cluster analysis of 62 variables produced eight thematic categories, offering a structured basis for hypothesis development and integrative model formulation. The review further identified critical research gaps, including limited empirical validation, methodological inconsistencies, and underutilization of theory in explaining outcomes. Findings reveal that vernacular design features such as courtyards, shading devices, and materiality strongly contribute to SIEQ, while contemporary transitions risk diminishing comfort. This review highlights critical research gaps, particularly evaluation voids and theoretical underuse, and proposes integrative directions for architects and policymakers.