Computational Efficiency–Accuracy Trade-Offs in EMT Modeling of ANPC Converters: Comparative Study and Real-Time HIL Validation

With the increasing demands of the grid on power electronic converters, active neutral-point-clamped (ANPC) converters have been widely adopted due to their flexible modulation strategies and wide-range power regulation capabilities. To address grid-integration testing requirements for ANPC converters, this paper comparatively studies three electromagnetic transient (EMT) modeling approaches: switch-state prediction method (SPM), associated discrete circuit (ADC), and time-averaged method (TAM). Steady-state and transient simulations reveal that the SPM model achieves the highest accuracy (error ≤ 0.018%), while the TAM-based switching function model optimizes the efficiency–accuracy trade-off with 6.4× speedup versus traditional methods and acceptable error (≤2.62%). Consequently, the TAM model is implemented in a real-time hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) platform. Validation under symmetrical/asymmetrical grid faults confirms both the model’s efficacy and the controller’s robust fault ride-through capability.