AI-Mediated Expert Wisdom Transmission: A Dual-Dimensional Framework of Process Alignment and Independent Retention

Background: Expert wisdom transmission faces an "internalization gap"—learners can reproduceanswers but struggle to reconstruct reasoning paths when confronting unfamiliar tasks. Whileartificial intelligence advances offer new opportunities for technologizing wisdom transmission,the field lacks unified evaluation frameworks and falsifiable implementation standards.Objective: This study proposes Expert Wisdom AI-fication Theory (EWAT), with the core being theestablishment of a dual-indicator evaluation system of Structural Correspondence Index (SCI) andCognitive Independence Index (CII), providing a measurable and reproducible technicalframework for AI-assisted wisdom transmission.Methods: We construct mapping models between Expert Process Profiles (EPP) and LearnerCognitive States (LCS), developing the Structural Correspondence Index (SCI) and CognitiveIndependence Index (CII) as evaluation tools. Three AI-assisted mechanisms are designed:Socratic questioning, minimalist process tracking, and desirable difficulty regulation. Fivefalsifiable propositions (P1-P5) are proposed for verification.Claims: Compared to traditional teaching methods, AI-assisted wisdom transmission withequivalent instructional inputs should yield: (1) higher process alignment (SCI); (2) strongerindependent retention capabilities (CII); (3) process features that outperform final grades inpredicting long-term performance.Boundaries: This study proposes a conceptual theoretical framework. All quantitative thresholdsrequire calibration and verification in practical applications; cross-cultural applicability requiresfurther research. When failures occur or dependence on external assistance rebounds,applications should be downgraded or suspended.Conclusion: EWAT provides an independence-first design language, supporting educationaltransformation from traditional knowledge transmission to deep capability activation, providing aframework foundation for open science replication and improvement.

Authors

Publication Details

Published
2025-09-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.35542/osf.io/k6ug9_v1
Primary Topic
Knowledge Management and Technology
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

AI-Mediated Expert Wisdom Transmission: A Dual-Dimensional Framework of Process Alignment and Independent Retention

Yang Guo-ping
Knowledge Management and Technology
article

AI-Mediated Expert Wisdom Transmission: A Dual-Dimensional Framework of Process Alignment and Independent Retention

Yang Guo-ping
article en

Abstract

Background: Expert wisdom transmission faces an "internalization gap"—learners can reproduceanswers but struggle to reconstruct reasoning paths when confronting unfamiliar tasks. Whileartificial intelligence advances offer new opportunities for technologizing wisdom transmission,the field lacks unified evaluation frameworks and falsifiable implementation standards.Objective: This study proposes Expert Wisdom AI-fication Theory (EWAT), with the core being theestablishment of a dual-indicator evaluation system of Structural Correspondence Index (SCI) andCognitive Independence Index (CII), providing a measurable and reproducible technicalframework for AI-assisted wisdom transmission.Methods: We construct mapping models between Expert Process Profiles (EPP) and LearnerCognitive States (LCS), developing the Structural Correspondence Index (SCI) and CognitiveIndependence Index (CII) as evaluation tools. Three AI-assisted mechanisms are designed:Socratic questioning, minimalist process tracking, and desirable difficulty regulation. Fivefalsifiable propositions (P1-P5) are proposed for verification.Claims: Compared to traditional teaching methods, AI-assisted wisdom transmission withequivalent instructional inputs should yield: (1) higher process alignment (SCI); (2) strongerindependent retention capabilities (CII); (3) process features that outperform final grades inpredicting long-term performance.Boundaries: This study proposes a conceptual theoretical framework. All quantitative thresholdsrequire calibration and verification in practical applications; cross-cultural applicability requiresfurther research. When failures occur or dependence on external assistance rebounds,applications should be downgraded or suspended.Conclusion: EWAT provides an independence-first design language, supporting educationaltransformation from traditional knowledge transmission to deep capability activation, providing aframework foundation for open science replication and improvement.

Openalex Percentile: Top 69%
Knowledge Management and Technology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.