Dynamics of Deterrence: A Macroeconomic Perspective on Punitive Justice Policy

ABSTRACT We argue that transitional dynamics play a critical role in evaluating the effects of punitive incarceration reform on crime, inequality, and labor markets. Individuals' past choices regarding crime and employment under previous policies have persistent consequences that limit their responsiveness to policy changes. A quantitative model of this theory, calibrated using administrative data, predicts nuanced dynamics of crime and incarceration that are distinct across property and violent crime and similar to the US experience after 1980. Increased inequality and declining employment accompany these changes, with unequal impacts across generations.