Evaluating Crown Defoliation Thresholds for the Identification of Trees Targeted for Sanitary Felling

Crown defoliation in trees is one of the indicators of forest tree vitality, and a primary criterion for selecting trees for sanitary felling. In Croatia, the selection of trees for sanitary felling includes all dead trees and those with crown defoliation greater than 60% (defoliation class 3a); in the past, the threshold for marking trees for sanitary felling was above 80% (class 3b). The aim of this study was to analyze tree mortality in pedunculate oak (Quercus robur), silver fir (Abies alba), and European beech (Fagus sylvatica), as well as crown regeneration, i.e., the reduction in defoliation. The analysis included a total of 7975 trees, comprising 1182 silver fir, 4221 European beech, and 2572 pedunculate oak trees, covering the period from 1998 to 2023. The mortality rate was 7.2% for silver fir, 2.16% for beech, and 9.6% for oak. The percentage of trees that regenerated their crowns or reduced defoliation to below 60% was 17.01% for fir, 4.33% for beech, and 12.51% for oak. Considering the proportion of silver fir and pedunculate oak trees whose defoliation decreased to below 60%, a defoliation threshold greater than 80% would be a more appropriate criterion for sanitary felling, except for European beech trees, for which there is a minimal difference between the recovery rates in classes 3a and 3b.