Comparative Assessment of Different Electrode Combinations for Phosphate Removal from Onsite Wastewater via Electrocoagulation

Phosphorus (P) discharge from onsite wastewater treatment systems (OWTSs) poses a significant threat to water quality, contributing to eutrophication in nutrient-sensitive aquatic environments. In treated effluents, P predominantly exists as orthophosphate (PO43−), a highly bioavailable and reactive form that requires targeted removal. This study evaluates the performance of electrocoagulation (EC) as a polishing step for PO43− removal from OWTS effluents using 12 anode/cathode combinations comprising aluminum (Al), iron (Fe), magnesium (Mg), and stainless steel (SS). Key operational parameters, including treatment time, mixing speed, current density, pH, and initial PO43− concentration, were systematically investigated when synthetic denitrified effluent (20 mg P/L) was treated. Based on the performance, the four most effective electrode combinations (Al/Al, Al/Mg, Fe/Al, and Mg/Mg), along with a commercial benchmark (Fe/Fe), were further tested under extended hydraulic retention times (up to 48 h) in both synthetic and real (denitrified) wastewater. To date, none of the studies have systematically evaluated all possible anode/cathode combinations involving multiple electrode materials under uniform operational conditions. The Al/Al and Mg/Mg EC systems achieved rapid and high PO43− removal efficiencies (>95%), while Mg-based systems demonstrated sustained performance over prolonged treatment durations, especially in real wastewater. Bimetallic pairs such as Al/Mg and Fe/Al exhibited synergistic effects through enhanced coagulant generation and pH stabilization. The results indicated that PO43− removal efficiency was strongly influenced by electrode material selection, hydrodynamic conditions, and wastewater compositions, underscoring the need to design EC systems based on site-specific water quality conditions in OWTSs.