Validation of Ecological Sustained Attention Test for Schizophrenia

Introduction Sustained attention deficit is a core feature of schizophrenia, however, its between-subjects and within-subject fluctuations are little understood. Moreover, although the pertinence of sustained attention for daily functioning has been widely discussed in the literature, research has not consistently demonstrated this association in schizophrenia. One possible reason is a use with non-ecological tasks for evaluation of SA, which may not fully capture real-world attentional demands. Indeed, existing tools demonstrate low ecological validity. Objectives This study aimed to develop daily-life task-based test of SA - Ecological Sustained Attention Task (Eco-SAT), and investigate its reliability and criterion, construct, and ecological validity in schizophrenia. Methods Eco-SAT was developed based on well-established CPT paradigm (320 trials presented for 500-3000ms, 12 min) simulating vacuum cleaning task. Twenty-one individuals with schizophrenia (age: M=42, SD=12.5; female: N=12, 57%) and 34 matched by age and gender healthy controls completed the Eco-SAT, non-ecological CPT, measures of cognition (MATRICS consensus cognitive battery: BACS, TMT, RBVMT & CFT), schizophrenia symptoms, and daily functioning using Observed Tasks of Daily Living test (OTDL, functional capacity) and Adults Subjective Assessment of Participation in daily life in an interchangeable order during one session. Results Eco-SAT demonstrated excellent test-retest reliability for Average RT (ICC = 0.84). Schizophrenia patients performed Eco-SAT significantly worse than controls on Average RT (U=545, p < 0.01), and variance RT (U=518, p < 0.01). Eco-SAT showed correlations with non-ecological SA task (all parameters; 0.45<r<0.75, p<.001), MATRICS sub-tests of BACS (d prime, average RT, RT variance: -0.54<r<0.3, p<.5), TMT-B (average RT: r=0.3, p<.05), RBVMT (average RT, RT variance: -0.5<r<-0.4, p<.01), and CFT (average RT, RT variance:-0.35<r<-0.34, p<.001), positive schizophrenia symptoms (hit rate: r=0.3, p<.05) and the OTDL (RT variance, d prime, hit rate: -0.35<r<0.3,p < .05). Conclusions The study provides initial evidence of the psychometric properties of the Eco-SAT, an ecological measure of sustained attention in schizophrenia. Criterion validity was established for all Eco-SAT indices, while reliability, construct validity, and ecological validity were demonstrated for specific indices. The results suggest that average RT and RT variance are the most trustworthy indices. Although further research is required, these findings indicate that this ecological measure may offer a more accurate way to assess attentional deficits in real-world activities, enhancing our understanding of attentional mechanisms in schizophrenia for both research and clinical applications. Disclosure of Interest None Declared

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
European Psychiatry
Published
2025-04-01
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2025.423
Primary Topic
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Validation of Ecological Sustained Attention Test for Schizophrenia

Reut Komemi, Mor Nahum, Lena Lipskaya‐Velikovsky, A. Ariel et al.
European Psychiatry
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
article

Validation of Ecological Sustained Attention Test for Schizophrenia

Reut Komemi, Mor Nahum, Lena Lipskaya‐Velikovsky, A. Ariel, T. Goldberger, A. Zagory
article en

Abstract

Introduction Sustained attention deficit is a core feature of schizophrenia, however, its between-subjects and within-subject fluctuations are little understood. Moreover, although the pertinence of sustained attention for daily functioning has been widely discussed in the literature, research has not consistently demonstrated this association in schizophrenia. One possible reason is a use with non-ecological tasks for evaluation of SA, which may not fully capture real-world attentional demands. Indeed, existing tools demonstrate low ecological validity. Objectives This study aimed to develop daily-life task-based test of SA - Ecological Sustained Attention Task (Eco-SAT), and investigate its reliability and criterion, construct, and ecological validity in schizophrenia. Methods Eco-SAT was developed based on well-established CPT paradigm (320 trials presented for 500-3000ms, 12 min) simulating vacuum cleaning task. Twenty-one individuals with schizophrenia (age: M=42, SD=12.5; female: N=12, 57%) and 34 matched by age and gender healthy controls completed the Eco-SAT, non-ecological CPT, measures of cognition (MATRICS consensus cognitive battery: BACS, TMT, RBVMT & CFT), schizophrenia symptoms, and daily functioning using Observed Tasks of Daily Living test (OTDL, functional capacity) and Adults Subjective Assessment of Participation in daily life in an interchangeable order during one session. Results Eco-SAT demonstrated excellent test-retest reliability for Average RT (ICC = 0.84). Schizophrenia patients performed Eco-SAT significantly worse than controls on Average RT (U=545, p < 0.01), and variance RT (U=518, p < 0.01). Eco-SAT showed correlations with non-ecological SA task (all parameters; 0.45<r<0.75, p<.001), MATRICS sub-tests of BACS (d prime, average RT, RT variance: -0.54<r<0.3, p<.5), TMT-B (average RT: r=0.3, p<.05), RBVMT (average RT, RT variance: -0.5<r<-0.4, p<.01), and CFT (average RT, RT variance:-0.35<r<-0.34, p<.001), positive schizophrenia symptoms (hit rate: r=0.3, p<.05) and the OTDL (RT variance, d prime, hit rate: -0.35<r<0.3,p < .05). Conclusions The study provides initial evidence of the psychometric properties of the Eco-SAT, an ecological measure of sustained attention in schizophrenia. Criterion validity was established for all Eco-SAT indices, while reliability, construct validity, and ecological validity were demonstrated for specific indices. The results suggest that average RT and RT variance are the most trustworthy indices. Although further research is required, these findings indicate that this ecological measure may offer a more accurate way to assess attentional deficits in real-world activities, enhancing our understanding of attentional mechanisms in schizophrenia for both research and clinical applications. Disclosure of Interest None Declared

European PsychiatryVol. 68(S1)
Hebrew College (US)
Openalex Percentile: Top 76%
Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.