Relation Between Physicians’ Emotional Response and Stigma Around Suicide

Introduction Suicide is a global health issue. Clinicians still have difficulties to differentiate patients who will or not commit suicide. This process is influenced by emotional and rational factors. Emotional responses (also known as countertransference) refers to what emotions clinicians experience. When working with suicidal patients, clinicians frequently experience negative emotions, such as fear, guilt and hopelessness. Clinicians’ negative emotions responses contribute to their assessment of risk. Possible factors that influence emotional responses are myths and beliefs around suicide, contributing to stigma. Objectives This study aims to investigate the relationship between emotional responses, knowledge and stigma about suicide when providing care to suicidal patients. Methods An anonymous web-based survey was implemented through the software REDCap. Data were collected by snowball sampling. Participation was voluntary and participants had the ability to opt out at any time. The study was approved by the University Ethics Committee. The survey consisted of the Informed Consent Form (ICF), Sociodemographic Questionnaire, Scale of Myths, Beliefs and Attitudes About Suicide (SMBAS) - which evaluates stigma about suicide trough true or false questions. We also included the Rating Scale for Countertransference (RSCT) which evaluates the main emotional responses towards suicidal patients, divided in approach, indifference or rejection. Other questionnaires were included for future research, beyond the scope of this study. Results From 210 respondents, 179 (85.2%) completed the questionnaire. Sociodemographics: 108 (60.3%) were female; 166 (92.7%) were self-declared white-colored skin; The mean age was 37.22 ( SD = 12.33), with 6 (0 to 48) median years of professional life [65(36.3%) were medical residents; 112(62.6%) were already specialists, 54(48.2%) of those declared to be psychiatrists]. Psychiatrists had highest rate of correct answers ( M = 28,96 , SD = 1,84) in SMBAS when compared with non-psychiatrists (M = 27,86, SD = 2,39 , p = 0,008); Psychiatrists presented more emotional responses of interest (M = 2,58, SD 0,68, p < 0,001), solidarity (M = 2,81, SD 0,45, p < 0,001) and desire to help (M = 2,83, SD 0,38, p = 0,010). Non-psychiatrists presented more emotional responses of hostility (M = 0,06, SD 0,25, p = 0,040) and distance (M = 0,32, SD 0,56, p = 0,002). Psychiatrists presented more approach (p=0,03) and non-psychiatrist indifference (p=0,03). Conclusions We find preliminary evidence that psychiatrist present higher knowledge around suicide theme, having lower stigma around suicide. Psychiatrists also present more countertransference of approach and less of indifference. Disclosure of Interest None Declared

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
European Psychiatry
Published
2025-04-01
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1192/j.eurpsy.2025.514
Primary Topic
Healthcare professionals’ stress and burnout
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Relation Between Physicians’ Emotional Response and Stigma Around Suicide

Gabriel Ibarra Zanella, Y. A. Ferrão, Rogério A.F. Monteiro, P. B. Bolzan et al.
European Psychiatry
Healthcare professionals’ stress and burnout
article

Relation Between Physicians’ Emotional Response and Stigma Around Suicide

Gabriel Ibarra Zanella, Y. A. Ferrão, Rogério A.F. Monteiro, P. B. Bolzan, T. P. Comissoli
article en

Abstract

Introduction Suicide is a global health issue. Clinicians still have difficulties to differentiate patients who will or not commit suicide. This process is influenced by emotional and rational factors. Emotional responses (also known as countertransference) refers to what emotions clinicians experience. When working with suicidal patients, clinicians frequently experience negative emotions, such as fear, guilt and hopelessness. Clinicians’ negative emotions responses contribute to their assessment of risk. Possible factors that influence emotional responses are myths and beliefs around suicide, contributing to stigma. Objectives This study aims to investigate the relationship between emotional responses, knowledge and stigma about suicide when providing care to suicidal patients. Methods An anonymous web-based survey was implemented through the software REDCap. Data were collected by snowball sampling. Participation was voluntary and participants had the ability to opt out at any time. The study was approved by the University Ethics Committee. The survey consisted of the Informed Consent Form (ICF), Sociodemographic Questionnaire, Scale of Myths, Beliefs and Attitudes About Suicide (SMBAS) - which evaluates stigma about suicide trough true or false questions. We also included the Rating Scale for Countertransference (RSCT) which evaluates the main emotional responses towards suicidal patients, divided in approach, indifference or rejection. Other questionnaires were included for future research, beyond the scope of this study. Results From 210 respondents, 179 (85.2%) completed the questionnaire. Sociodemographics: 108 (60.3%) were female; 166 (92.7%) were self-declared white-colored skin; The mean age was 37.22 ( SD = 12.33), with 6 (0 to 48) median years of professional life [65(36.3%) were medical residents; 112(62.6%) were already specialists, 54(48.2%) of those declared to be psychiatrists]. Psychiatrists had highest rate of correct answers ( M = 28,96 , SD = 1,84) in SMBAS when compared with non-psychiatrists (M = 27,86, SD = 2,39 , p = 0,008); Psychiatrists presented more emotional responses of interest (M = 2,58, SD 0,68, p < 0,001), solidarity (M = 2,81, SD 0,45, p < 0,001) and desire to help (M = 2,83, SD 0,38, p = 0,010). Non-psychiatrists presented more emotional responses of hostility (M = 0,06, SD 0,25, p = 0,040) and distance (M = 0,32, SD 0,56, p = 0,002). Psychiatrists presented more approach (p=0,03) and non-psychiatrist indifference (p=0,03). Conclusions We find preliminary evidence that psychiatrist present higher knowledge around suicide theme, having lower stigma around suicide. Psychiatrists also present more countertransference of approach and less of indifference. Disclosure of Interest None Declared

European PsychiatryVol. 68(S1)
Universidade Federal de Ciências da Saúde de Porto Alegre (BR), Hospital Materno-Infantil (ES), Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam (NL)
Openalex Percentile: Top 61%
Healthcare professionals’ stress and burnout
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.