Maieutic, Natural, and Artificial Forms in Automatic Control Case Study

Maieutics is a remarkable method for discovering new insights through deep dialogue. Defined as “relating to or resembling the Socratic method of eliciting new ideas from another”, the term originates from the Greek word for “midwifery”—as noted in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Recently, maieutics has gained renewed relevance in advanced discussions about artificial intelligence, the nature of the mind, and scientific inquiry. This contribution presents a real and extended dialogue, illustrating the power of the maieutic method in addressing key developments in the field of Automatic Control. Over the past 40 years, the authors have followed a unique intellectual path shaped by this method. Inspired by recent research, they have also applied maieutics in interaction with AI systems—particularly ChatGPT. This experiment aimed to replicate, in a condensed timeframe, the long intellectual journey taken over decades. The preliminary results suggest that although AI systems can retrieve historical information, they struggle to capture the deeper, guiding principles of this journey. The authors also identify a significant concern: while the maieutic approach with ChatGPT can serve as a valuable educational tool, it must be complemented by a strong knowledge of dynamical systems leading to innovative paradigms of learning.