In Situ Winter Performance and Annual Energy Assessment of an Ultra-Lightweight, Soil-Free Green Roof in Mediterranean Climate: Comparison with Traditional Roof Insulation

Green roofs are effective passive strategies for enhancing building energy efficiency and indoor thermal comfort, particularly in response to climate change. This study presents an experimental and numerical assessment of an ultra-lightweight, soil-free green roof system for Mediterranean climates. In situ thermal monitoring was carried out on two identical test rooms in Rome (Italy), comparing the green roof to a traditional tiled roof under winter conditions. Results revealed a 45% reduction in thermal transmittance. These data were used to calibrate a dynamic TRNSYS 18 model and then applied to annual simulations of energy demand and indoor comfort across different roof configurations, including expanded polystyrene-insulated reference roofs. The model was calibrated in accordance with ASHRAE Guideline 14, achieving an MBE within ±10% and a CV(RMSE) within ±30% for hourly data, ensuring the simulation’s reliability. The green roof reduced cooling energy demand by up to 58.5% and heating demand by 11.6% relative to the uninsulated reference case. Compared to insulated roofs, it maintained similar winter performance while achieving summer operative temperature reductions up to 0.99 °C and PPD decreases up to 2.94%. By combining field measurements with calibrated simulations, this work provides evidence of the green roof’s effectiveness as a passive retrofit solution for Mediterranean buildings.