Understanding Channel Access in Timely Status Updates: Random Access or Scheduled Access?

We investigate the role of channel access schemes in enhancing the timeliness of status updates in sensor networks. Specifically, we model the large-scale sensor network as a Poisson cellular network and derive the network average Age of Information (AoI) under two channel access schemes: random and scheduled access. Our findings reveal that the effectiveness of these schemes is influenced by the signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) decoding threshold, which often reflects the length of communication data. For short-packet communications, performance differences among various channel access strategies are minimal, and the gains from scheduling are limited; in fact, some simple scheduling strategies may not outperform basic random strategies. Conversely, scheduled access schemes demonstrate a distinct performance advantage for long-packet communications. The round robin scheme consistently yields the best performance among the four protocols we examined-slotted ALOHA, frame slotted ALOHA, random scheduling, and round robin scheduling. This is due to its ability to mitigate intra-cell interference and regularize both status updates and channel access periods for each sensor, which is particularly beneficial in reducing AoI.