Technical note: Comparing ozone production efficiency (OPE) of chemical mechanisms using chemical process analysis (CPA)

Abstract. Chemical mechanisms are critical to chemical transport models for air quality research and policy analysis. Several mechanisms are available and intercomparison, especially using metrics which reduce sensitivity to modeling scenario, is important for interpreting results and assessing uncertainties. Here, we investigate Ozone Production Efficiency (OPE) as a comparison metric under conditions where nitrogen oxides (NOX) are limited. OPE is the net number of ozone molecules produced per NOX molecule lost and can be computed in simulations using chemical process analysis (CPA). We compute OPE (OPE-CPA) for four chemical mechanisms (CB6r5, CB7r1, SAPRC07, RACM2) and find a similar response to varying anthropogenic emissions of volatile organic compounds (VOC) and NOX. RACM2 consistently produces the largest OPE-CPA and differences between mechanisms are greatest at high VOC/NOX ratios. The high RACM2 OPE-CPA is partially due to a slower OH + NO2 rate and potentially to its treatment of NOX recycling. OPE-CPA is generally consistent with aircraft OPE measurements downwind of Houston but direct comparison is difficult due to uncertainties in deposition and VOC speciation. More recent OPE measurements are required to determine whether trends over time are consistent. OPE-CPA responds nonlinearly to NOX and increases at low NOX even as ozone production decreases. Using OPE to predict ozone response to NOX emissions reductions is therefore an oversimplification that will tend to overstate ozone reductions. OPE-CPA is a viable metric to compare mechanisms, however, additional work would be helpful to define standardized conditions for comparisons.