Comparative Carbon Footprint Analysis of Alumina-Based Multichannel and Hollow Fiber Ceramic Membranes for Microfiltration

This study aims to compare the carbon footprints associated with the fabrication of two types of alumina-based tubular ceramic membranes used in microfiltration (MF): a multichannel membrane produced by extrusion and dip-coating, and an asymmetric hollow fiber membrane fabricated via phase inversion. The multichannel process involves two sintering steps but uses no organic solvents, whereas the phase-inversion method simplifies production through single-step shaping and sintering but requires organic solvents that increase environmental burdens. Using a functional unit of 1 m2 effective membrane area, carbon emissions were quantified from raw material extraction to waste disposal. The results showed total emissions of 8.57 kg CO2-eq/m2 for the multichannel membrane and 10.67 kg CO2-eq/m2 for the hollow fiber membrane. Although the hollow fiber process consumed less energy, its extensive use of solvents, particularly NMP, led to significantly higher emissions. This study provides the first quantitative comparison of these two common ceramic membrane fabrication routes and underscores the importance of considering both energy use and solvent impacts when evaluating the environmental sustainability of membrane production. A sensitivity analysis further evaluated the influence of key parameters, including alumina emission factor, regional electricity carbon intensity, alumina recycling, and solvent substitution or NMP recycling. The analysis demonstrated that each factor could significantly influence the total carbon footprint and, under favorable conditions, narrow or even reverse the gap between the two fabrication routes. This study provides the first quantitative comparison of these two common ceramic membrane fabrication methods and highlights the importance of considering energy use, solvent impacts, and potential mitigation strategies when assessing the environmental sustainability of ceramic membrane production.