Analysis of Selective Pressure on Ancient Human Mitochondrial Genomes Reveals the Presence of Widespread Sequencing Artefacts

Human mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is a relevant marker in evolutionary and population genetics, including ancient DNA (aDNA) research, due to inherent characteristics. However, aDNA is prone to damage and sequencing artefacts, potentially confounding evolutionary interpretations. To assess evolutionary patterns in ancient and modern mtDNA, we built a phylogeny comprising 63,965 modern and 3757 ancient public mitogenomes, classified mutations by genomic region and functional effect, and analysed distribution, frequency, and predicted pathogenicity of private and pre-terminal mutations, investigating purifying selection. We compared mutation class ratios (non-synonymous, rRNA, tRNA, nonsense vs. synonymous) across ancient and modern terminal branches and pre-terminal nodes. The predicted pathogenicity of non-synonymous mutations was evaluated across major European haplogroups using three tools. Ancient variants exhibited higher ratios of potentially deleterious mutations and significantly elevated pathogenicity scores compared to modern and pre-terminal branches, highlighting a mutation load likely inflated by damage-related artefacts. Remarkably, nonsense mutations-largely incompatible with life-were over 70 times more frequent in aDNA. The correlation between mutation ratios and predicted deleteriousness across haplogroups suggests a pattern incompatible with biological persistence or relaxed selection alone. These findings highlight the importance of rigorous quality control for ancient data in evolutionary inference, molecular clock calibration, and pathogenic variant identification.