Impact of Natural Transformation on the Acquisition of Novel Genes in Bacteria

Natural transformation is the only process of gene exchange under the exclusive control of the recipient bacteria. It has often been considered as a source of novel genes, but quantitative assessments of this claim are lacking. To investigate the potential role of natural transformation in gene acquisition, we analyzed a large collection of genomes of Acinetobacter baumannii (Ab) and Legionella pneumophila (Lp) for which transformation rates were experimentally determined. Natural transformation rates are weakly correlated with genome size. But they are negatively associated with gene turnover in both species. This might result from a negative balance between the transformation's ability to cure the chromosome from mobile genetic elements (MGEs), resulting in gene loss, and its facilitation of gene acquisition. By comparing gene gains by transformation and MGEs, we found that transformation was associated with the acquisition of small sets of genes per event, which were also spread more evenly in the chromosome. We estimated the contribution of natural transformation to gene gains by comparing recombination-driven gene acquisition rates between transformable and non-transformable strains, finding that it facilitated the acquisition of ca. 6.4% (Ab) and 1.1% (Lp) of the novel genes. This moderate contribution of natural transformation to gene acquisition implies that most novel genes are acquired by other means. Yet, 15% of the recently acquired antibiotic resistance genes in A. baumannii may have been acquired by transformation. Hence, natural transformation may drive the acquisition of relatively few novel genes, but these may have a high fitness impact.