Historically Informed Vocal Performance in the Mirror of Modern Musicological Research

This article offers a concise overview of scholarly literature on the issue of Historically Informed Performance (HIP) in the sphere of vocal music. Special emphasis is placed on contributions by Ukrainian researchers (M. Marchenko, Ye. Lazarevych, L. Artyukhova, O. Tabulina, D. Savon, A. Kolyada). M. Marchenko, in particular, examined the features of performance strategies and interpretive models of national part-song heritage. Ye. Lazarevych analyzed Ukrainian liturgical music from the perspective of HIP, drawing on performances by the “Byzantine Choir” conducted by M. Antonovych. L. Artyukhova proposed several approaches to interpreting Baroque music by contemporary vocalists – academic, authentic, and synthesized. The specificities of Western European Renaissance choral music performance in Ukraine were explored in the work of N. Danshyna. O. Tabulina addressed the appropriateness of vibrato as a component of vocal technique in Baroque compositions. D. Savon investigated the vocal style of German Baroque choral music through both scholarly and performance-based lenses. A. Kolyada emphasized the significant sociocultural role of the independent platform “Open Opera Ukraine”, which actively promotes HIP in Ukraine. For the first time, the article also considers two foreign studies (R. Wistrich, J. Potter, and K. A. Henshaw). R. Wistrich and J. Potter argue against narrowly defined vocal specializations, advocating instead for a close integration of training and scholarship, as well as for vocal versatility in historically grounded performance practice. K. A. Henshaw explored the relationship between semiotic gestures in vocal performance and specific musical- rhetorical figures characteristic of the Baroque era. Drawing from this diverse body of work, the article identifies several key perspectives on early vocal music performance: historical-stylistic (L. Artyukhova, N. Danshyna), genre-specific (M. Marchenko, D. Savon), organizational-aesthetic (R. Wistrich and J. Potter, A. Kolyada, Ye. Lazarevych), and integrative-semiotic (K. A. Henshaw).

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Ukrainian music
Published
2025-01-01
DOI
https://doi.org/10.32782/2224-0926-2025-2-53-4
Primary Topic
Diverse Musicological Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Historically Informed Vocal Performance in the Mirror of Modern Musicological Research

Mariia Hryhorieva
Ukrainian music
Diverse Musicological Studies
article

Historically Informed Vocal Performance in the Mirror of Modern Musicological Research

Mariia Hryhorieva
article en

Abstract

This article offers a concise overview of scholarly literature on the issue of Historically Informed Performance (HIP) in the sphere of vocal music. Special emphasis is placed on contributions by Ukrainian researchers (M. Marchenko, Ye. Lazarevych, L. Artyukhova, O. Tabulina, D. Savon, A. Kolyada). M. Marchenko, in particular, examined the features of performance strategies and interpretive models of national part-song heritage. Ye. Lazarevych analyzed Ukrainian liturgical music from the perspective of HIP, drawing on performances by the “Byzantine Choir” conducted by M. Antonovych. L. Artyukhova proposed several approaches to interpreting Baroque music by contemporary vocalists – academic, authentic, and synthesized. The specificities of Western European Renaissance choral music performance in Ukraine were explored in the work of N. Danshyna. O. Tabulina addressed the appropriateness of vibrato as a component of vocal technique in Baroque compositions. D. Savon investigated the vocal style of German Baroque choral music through both scholarly and performance-based lenses. A. Kolyada emphasized the significant sociocultural role of the independent platform “Open Opera Ukraine”, which actively promotes HIP in Ukraine. For the first time, the article also considers two foreign studies (R. Wistrich, J. Potter, and K. A. Henshaw). R. Wistrich and J. Potter argue against narrowly defined vocal specializations, advocating instead for a close integration of training and scholarship, as well as for vocal versatility in historically grounded performance practice. K. A. Henshaw explored the relationship between semiotic gestures in vocal performance and specific musical- rhetorical figures characteristic of the Baroque era. Drawing from this diverse body of work, the article identifies several key perspectives on early vocal music performance: historical-stylistic (L. Artyukhova, N. Danshyna), genre-specific (M. Marchenko, D. Savon), organizational-aesthetic (R. Wistrich and J. Potter, A. Kolyada, Ye. Lazarevych), and integrative-semiotic (K. A. Henshaw).

Ukrainian music(2(53))
Openalex Percentile: Top 79%
Diverse Musicological Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.