Awaiting for Godot : stateless model checking that avoids executions where nothing happens

Stateless Model Checking (SMC) is a verification technique for concurrent programs that checks for safety violations by exploring all possible thread schedulings. It is highly effective when coupled with Dynamic Partial Order Reduction (DPOR), which introduces an equivalence on schedulings and allows SMC to explore only one execution per equivalence class. Even with DPOR, SMC often spends unnecessary effort in exploring loop iterations that are pure, i.e., have no effect on the program state. In this article, we present techniques for making SMC with DPOR more effective on programs with pure loop iterations. The first technique is a static program analysis to detect loop purity and an associated program transformation, called Partial Loop Purity Elimination, that inserts assume statements to block pure loop iterations. Subsequently, some of these assume statements are turned into await statements that completely remove many assume-blocked executions. Finally, we present an extension of the standard DPOR equivalence, obtained by weakening the conflict relation between events. All these techniques are incorporated into a new DPOR algorithm, Optimal-DPOR-Await, which can handle both await statements and the weaker conflict relation, is optimal in the sense that it explores exactly one execution in each equivalence class, and can also diagnose livelocks. Our implementation in Nidhugg shows that these techniques can significantly speed up the analysis of concurrent programs that are currently challenging for SMC tools, both for exploring their complete set of interleavings, but even for detecting concurrency errors in them.