Sacred Places in Ukrainian and Polish Narratives about Resettlement from the Flood Zone

A comparative analysis of the concepts of church and cemetery in oral historical narratives and written memoirs about forced resettlement from flood zones in Ukraine and Poland is conducted in the work. Attention is traced to the fact of the destruction or relocation of the church, as well as to the relocation of cemeteries in the Ukrainian and Polish resettlement narrative. The oral history of resettlement conveys the idea of community unity in the semantic field of the church concept. The kermis in their former village has become the date for annual meetings of residents of resettled villages. The semantic field of the cemetery concept conveys the idea of the impossibility of complete resettlement: it is impossible to relocate everything, there will definitely be losses. And it is on these losses that the narrators focus the main attention in their narratives. The interpretation of the forced relocation as a traumatic experience is common in these resettlement narratives. These stories are primarily a transfer of the experience of loss. The home is an important spatial object that all resettlers necessarily talk about. This is primarily their parents’ or their own, destroyed house, and they talk less about the newly built house. The storytellers connect the flooded village image with their birthplace, childhood years; they idealize the lost space, focus on the construction of a new home, in particular on mutual assistance and the struggle to obtain building materials. The collapse of the community, friendly and neighborly relations is another important theme in the interviews. Memories on the transfer of cemeteries in the resettlement narratives are filled with anxiety, bitterness and mysticism. The unnaturalness of the loss of an ancient cemetery site gives rise to ideas conditioned by the ideological prohibition to disturb the dead, and even more so by the fact that not all coffins were reburied. This moment is especially clearly traced in the Ukrainian narrative tradition, where there were even laments for flooded graves that could not be moved. The concept of church is verbalized in the following plots and motifs: information about the destruction or change of purpose of the church; features of religious life in a village without a church; the fate of preserved churches; modern meetings of displaced persons on the days of the temple holiday of former villages; change of purpose of the church in Soviet times; God’s punishment for causing damage to the church. The idea of the most severe loss as a result of resettlement is conveyed in the semantic field of the concept of home. The concept of land conveys the idea of the injustice of resettlement, the concept of cemetery includes the idea of the impossibility of complete resettlement, and the concept of church contains the idea of community unity. Comparative studies conducted in different countries on communities with similar traumatic experiences allow for a deeper, more detailed understanding of what is common and different in the conditioned, verbalized worldview of the past.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Slov'ânsʹkij svìt.
Published
2024-12-30
DOI
https://doi.org/10.15407/slavicworld2024.23.105
Primary Topic
Polish Historical and Cultural Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Sacred Places in Ukrainian and Polish Narratives about Resettlement from the Flood Zone

Iryna Koval-Fuchylo
Slov'ânsʹkij svìt.
Polish Historical and Cultural Studies
article

Sacred Places in Ukrainian and Polish Narratives about Resettlement from the Flood Zone

Iryna Koval-Fuchylo
article en

Abstract

A comparative analysis of the concepts of church and cemetery in oral historical narratives and written memoirs about forced resettlement from flood zones in Ukraine and Poland is conducted in the work. Attention is traced to the fact of the destruction or relocation of the church, as well as to the relocation of cemeteries in the Ukrainian and Polish resettlement narrative. The oral history of resettlement conveys the idea of community unity in the semantic field of the church concept. The kermis in their former village has become the date for annual meetings of residents of resettled villages. The semantic field of the cemetery concept conveys the idea of the impossibility of complete resettlement: it is impossible to relocate everything, there will definitely be losses. And it is on these losses that the narrators focus the main attention in their narratives. The interpretation of the forced relocation as a traumatic experience is common in these resettlement narratives. These stories are primarily a transfer of the experience of loss. The home is an important spatial object that all resettlers necessarily talk about. This is primarily their parents’ or their own, destroyed house, and they talk less about the newly built house. The storytellers connect the flooded village image with their birthplace, childhood years; they idealize the lost space, focus on the construction of a new home, in particular on mutual assistance and the struggle to obtain building materials. The collapse of the community, friendly and neighborly relations is another important theme in the interviews. Memories on the transfer of cemeteries in the resettlement narratives are filled with anxiety, bitterness and mysticism. The unnaturalness of the loss of an ancient cemetery site gives rise to ideas conditioned by the ideological prohibition to disturb the dead, and even more so by the fact that not all coffins were reburied. This moment is especially clearly traced in the Ukrainian narrative tradition, where there were even laments for flooded graves that could not be moved. The concept of church is verbalized in the following plots and motifs: information about the destruction or change of purpose of the church; features of religious life in a village without a church; the fate of preserved churches; modern meetings of displaced persons on the days of the temple holiday of former villages; change of purpose of the church in Soviet times; God’s punishment for causing damage to the church. The idea of the most severe loss as a result of resettlement is conveyed in the semantic field of the concept of home. The concept of land conveys the idea of the injustice of resettlement, the concept of cemetery includes the idea of the impossibility of complete resettlement, and the concept of church contains the idea of community unity. Comparative studies conducted in different countries on communities with similar traumatic experiences allow for a deeper, more detailed understanding of what is common and different in the conditioned, verbalized worldview of the past.

Slov'ânsʹkij svìt.(23)
Openalex Percentile: Top 50%
Polish Historical and Cultural Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.