Bandit-Based Prompt Design Strategy Selection Improves Prompt Optimizers

Prompt optimization aims to search for effective prompts that enhance the performance of large language models (LLMs).Although existing prompt optimization methods have discovered effective prompts, they often differ from sophisticated prompts carefully designed by human experts.Prompt design strategies, representing best practices for improving prompt performance, can be key to improving prompt optimization.Recently, a method termed the Autonomous Prompt Engineering Toolbox (APET) has incorporated various prompt design strategies into the prompt optimization process.In APET, the LLM is needed to implicitly select and apply the appropriate strategies because prompt design strategies can have negative effects.This implicit selection may be suboptimal due to the limited optimization capabilities of LLMs.This paper introduces Optimizing Prompts with sTrategy Selection (OPTS), which implements explicit selection mechanisms for prompt design.We propose three mechanisms, including a Thompson sampling-based approach, and integrate them into EvoPrompt, a well-known prompt optimizer.Experiments optimizing prompts for two LLMs, Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-4o mini, were conducted using BIG-Bench Hard.Our results show that the selection of prompt design strategies improves the performance of EvoPrompt, and the Thompson samplingbased mechanism achieves the best overall results.Our experimental code is provided at https://github.com/shiralab/OPTS. K descriptions of prompt design strategiesOption not using prompt design strategies Meta-prompt: e.g.) Modify the prompt using prompt design strategy. The description of selected prompt design strategyPrompt: e.g.) Evaluate the result of a random Boolean expression.