The Comprehensive Benefit Evaluation of Urban Drainage Culverts and Pipes Based on Combination Weighting

The urban drainage system is a significant lifeline for ensuring the safe operation of a city. In recent years, defects and diseases in drainage pipes and their ancillary facilities have occurred frequently. Aiming to provide decision-makers with comprehensive benefit evaluation support, we chose to evaluate the security, environmental, social, and economic benefits of urban drainage culverts and pipes (UDCPs). An index system of 14 first-level indicators in four dimensions was established, and the indicators contain 28 influencing factors. The index weight was obtained by combining the analytical hierarchy process and entropy weight method, and the weights assigned to the security, environmental, social, and economic benefits were 0.448, 0.222, 0.202, and 0.128, respectively. The evaluation system was developed on the basis of a geographic information system (GIS), and the topological analysis of the GIS was applied in the calculation. To process the questionnaire results, this study adopted the automatic questionnaire analysis and scoring method combining natural language processing and optical character recognition technology. The method was applied in the study area in southern China, which contains 9 catchment areas and 1356 pipes. The results show that about 5% of the pipelines need to be included in the renewal plan. For UDCP renewal, the findings provide a decision-making tool of the comprehensive analysis for the selection of engineering technologies and the evaluation of the implementation effects.