A new subsurface temperature model for Ireland from joint geophysical–petrological inversion of seismic, surface heat flow and petrophysical data

SUMMARY High-quality maps of subsurface temperature and the geothermal gradient are useful when assessing the geothermal potential of a region. However, determining geothermal potential is a challenge when direct measurements of in-situ temperature and thermal property information are sparse and indirect geophysical methods are sensitive to a range of parameters, not just temperature. Here, we produce subsurface temperature maps of Ireland using a joint geophysical–petrological inversion, where seismic and other geophysical and petrophysical data are inverted directly for temperature in 1-D columns and are collated into a pseudo 3-D temperature volume. Additionally, the inversion produces new models for Moho and LAB depth and for the average crustal radiogenic heat production. To assess the robustness of the resulting temperature model, an uncertainty analysis has been performed by inverting all of the 1-D columns for a range of reasonable input parameters applicable to the Irish crust (rather than the ‘best’ input parameters). The resulting uncertainty model suggests temperature estimates at 2 km depth in our model could vary by ± 2 to 5 °C with an average of 3.5 °C in most locations. The uncertainty model can be used to assess confidence in different regions of the temperature model. In addition, 3-D forward modelling was performed to assess the lateral heat flow variations when compared to the purely 1-D inversion. The upper-crustal geothermal gradient ranges from 20 to 40 °C km−1 indicating a higher geothermal gradient for Ireland than previously reported with subsurface temperatures at 2 km depth > 60 °C everywhere, sufficient for residential and industrial heating purposes. The temperature gradient is typically higher in areas with thinner lithosphere. However, in some locations, the observed geotherms are elevated further due to high radiogenic heat production in granitic rocks. In Northern Ireland, a thin lithosphere, coupled with a weakly conductive basalt layer overlying warm crust, results in elevated temperatures. These are the first temperature maps for Ireland that include uncertainty estimates, providing ranges for the subsurface temperature values, and demonstrate that the maps are comparable to direct independent borehole temperature measurements, which are observed to fall within the model uncertainty. Our new methodology provides workflows for determining the geothermal potential in areas with limited direct temperature measurements. The final temperature model with uncertainty provides useful constraints for geothermal exploration and utilization on the island of Ireland.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Geophysical Journal International
Published
2025-07-24
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1093/gji/ggaf281
Primary Topic
Geothermal Energy Systems and Applications
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

A new subsurface temperature model for Ireland from joint geophysical–petrological inversion of seismic, surface heat flow and petrophysical data

Sarah Blake, Duygu Kiyan, Sergei Lebedev, Emma L. Chambers et al.
Geophysical Journal International
Geothermal Energy Systems and Applications
article

A new subsurface temperature model for Ireland from joint geophysical–petrological inversion of seismic, surface heat flow and petrophysical data

Sarah Blake, Duygu Kiyan, Sergei Lebedev, Emma L. Chambers, Javier Fullea, J. Stephen Daly, Robert J. Raine, Christopher J. Bean, Nicola Willmot Noller, B. M. O’Reilly, Patrick A Meere
article en

Abstract

SUMMARY High-quality maps of subsurface temperature and the geothermal gradient are useful when assessing the geothermal potential of a region. However, determining geothermal potential is a challenge when direct measurements of in-situ temperature and thermal property information are sparse and indirect geophysical methods are sensitive to a range of parameters, not just temperature. Here, we produce subsurface temperature maps of Ireland using a joint geophysical–petrological inversion, where seismic and other geophysical and petrophysical data are inverted directly for temperature in 1-D columns and are collated into a pseudo 3-D temperature volume. Additionally, the inversion produces new models for Moho and LAB depth and for the average crustal radiogenic heat production. To assess the robustness of the resulting temperature model, an uncertainty analysis has been performed by inverting all of the 1-D columns for a range of reasonable input parameters applicable to the Irish crust (rather than the ‘best’ input parameters). The resulting uncertainty model suggests temperature estimates at 2 km depth in our model could vary by ± 2 to 5 °C with an average of 3.5 °C in most locations. The uncertainty model can be used to assess confidence in different regions of the temperature model. In addition, 3-D forward modelling was performed to assess the lateral heat flow variations when compared to the purely 1-D inversion. The upper-crustal geothermal gradient ranges from 20 to 40 °C km−1 indicating a higher geothermal gradient for Ireland than previously reported with subsurface temperatures at 2 km depth > 60 °C everywhere, sufficient for residential and industrial heating purposes. The temperature gradient is typically higher in areas with thinner lithosphere. However, in some locations, the observed geotherms are elevated further due to high radiogenic heat production in granitic rocks. In Northern Ireland, a thin lithosphere, coupled with a weakly conductive basalt layer overlying warm crust, results in elevated temperatures. These are the first temperature maps for Ireland that include uncertainty estimates, providing ranges for the subsurface temperature values, and demonstrate that the maps are comparable to direct independent borehole temperature measurements, which are observed to fall within the model uncertainty. Our new methodology provides workflows for determining the geothermal potential in areas with limited direct temperature measurements. The final temperature model with uncertainty provides useful constraints for geothermal exploration and utilization on the island of Ireland.

Geophysical Journal InternationalVol. 243(1)
University College Dublin (IE), Universidad Complutense de Madrid (ES), United States Geological Survey (US), Dublin Institute For Advanced Studies (IE), Geological Survey of Ireland (IE), British Geological Survey (GB), University of Cambridge (GB), University College Cork (IE), Bridge University (SS), Work Research Centre (IE), Department of Earth Sciences (RU)
Science Foundation Ireland, Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación, European Regional Development Fund
Openalex Percentile: Top 89%
Geothermal Energy Systems and Applications
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.